01
Essential Ohio Valley square-cut
DiCarlo's Pizza – Rayland
Rayland, Just South Of Connorville • Classic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Must-Try For Regional Style
Thin, airy squares with cheese added after the bake make DiCarlo's in Rayland a staple stop for pizza lovers near Connorville.
If you want to understand Ohio Valley pizza, this is the place to start. The crust comes out crisp but light, with sauce baked on and a snowfall of cheese added right before it hits the box, so every bite feels fresh and a little different from typical chain pies. It is a simple, no-frills setup that rewards eating your slices as soon as you get to the car.
02
Loaded topping favorite
DeFelice Bros Pizza – Yorkville
Yorkville Riverfront • Neighborhood Delivery-And-Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Hearty, Loaded Pies
DeFelice Bros in Yorkville leans into generous toppings and sturdy crusts that hold up for game nights and big family orders.
This spot is all about crowd-pleasing comfort, from thick runs of pepperoni to deluxe pies that practically sag under the toppings. The crust has enough chew to stand up to a long drive back to Connorville, which makes it a smart pick when you are feeding a group. Round out the order with wings or a sub and you have an easy one-stop dinner run along the river.
03
Old-school valley institution
Giannamore's Pizza – Wintersville
Wintersville Hilltop Strip • Counter-Service Italian Bakery And Pizzeria • Beloved Longtime Favorite
Giannamore's in Wintersville serves nostalgic, bakery-style pies and Italian breads that many locals grew up on.
Expect a softer, bready crust with a slightly sweet sauce and a straightforward topping lineup that feels very old-school in the best way. The shop has a steady takeout rhythm, with locals grabbing boxes of pizza and pepperoni rolls for family gatherings and Friday nights. It is a bit of a drive from Connorville, but the combination of pizza and fresh-baked goodies makes it worth planning around.
04
Sit-down Italian with solid pies
Naples Spaghetti House – Steubenville
Steubenville, Just Off Downtown • Full-Service Italian Restaurant • Best For Leisurely Dinners
Naples Spaghetti House pairs classic thin-crust pizzas with hearty pasta plates in a retro, family-friendly dining room.
When you want pizza but also a proper sit-down meal, this old-school Steubenville favorite hits a nice middle ground. The pizzas lean thinner with a crisp edge, making them easy to share alongside big bowls of spaghetti and house red sauce. It is the kind of place where multi-generation families slide into the same booths week after week, which says a lot about how consistent it is.
05
Reliable chain option
Domino's Pizza – Steubenville
Steubenville West Side • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Big Orders
Domino's in Steubenville is the go-to when you need fast delivery, customizable crusts, and sides that can feed a crowd without much planning.
For college move-ins, late kickoffs, or nights when everyone wants something different, this spot is more about convenience than ceremony. You can build out everything from thin-crust pepperoni to pan pizzas loaded with extra cheese, then pile on wings, breads, and desserts in the same order. It is not the most romantic choice, but it reliably fills the table when time and budget are the main concerns.