Continental has a laid-back pizza scene, anchored by a small-town shop and supported by reliable ovens in the surrounding farm country. Within a short drive you can find everything from quick carryout chains to old-school regional joints that take pride in their dough. These five picks give you easy choices whether you’re grabbing a box on the way home or planning a casual night out.
Classic, generously topped pies served in a friendly, no-fuss village hangout.
This is the spot most locals mention first when you ask where to get pizza in Continental. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, and the staff does well with call-ahead carryout on busy nights. It’s also laid-back enough for a quick dine-in meal after a game or a day on the road.
Well-known chain spot with consistent crust, lots of topping combos, and easy online ordering.
Ottawa’s Marco’s is a go-to when you want something predictable and hot without lingering around a dining room. The sauce leans a little sweet, and the menu lets you build your own or lean on specialty pies and chewy cheesy bread. It’s especially handy for weeknight dinners or feeding a small group back at the house.
Fast, inexpensive pizza that works when you care more about speed and price than lingering over a meal.
For quick fuel between errands or before a long drive, Ottawa’s Little Caesars handles the basics—hot-and-ready pies, crazy bread, and big orders without much notice. The focus is on value and convenience rather than atmosphere. It’s a smart move when you’re feeding kids or a crowd on a tight budget.
Thick, chewy crust and generous cheese make this Defiance standby a solid choice for a fuller, sit-down pizza meal.
A.J.’s Heavenly Pizza leans into hearty, Midwestern-style pies with plenty of cheese and toppings that push right to the edge. The dining room is relaxed and family-friendly, so you can linger over a pie instead of rushing back to the car. It’s a nice change of pace when you want more of an evening out than a quick grab-and-go.
Lima’s Fat Jack’s turns out big, flavorful pizzas that feel built for sharing after a ballgame or road trip.
The crust here lands between thin and pan-style, with a satisfying chew and enough structure for heavier toppings. Portions run large, and the menu usually covers everything from straightforward pepperoni to specialty combos. If you don’t mind the drive from Continental, it’s a fun option when you want pizza to be the main event.