Coolville keeps things quiet, but there’s no need to travel far for a solid pizza night. Within a short drive you’ll find everything from classic small-town pies to college-town slices and creative artisan combos. These five spots are the places locals lean on when they’re craving a pie after a ballgame, a river drive, or a trip into Athens.
Your go-to Coolville stop for a straightforward pie and a friendly, no-rush vibe.
Larry’s is the kind of place where the staff remembers regulars and a hot pepperoni pie feels like a Friday night tradition. The crust leans classic and chewy, with plenty of cheese and just enough crunch at the edge. It’s especially handy when you want pizza without leaving the village limits.
A short drive from Coolville for big, bold pies with inventive toppings and serious crust.
Athens locals know Avalanche as the spot for off-the-wall combinations and thoughtfully made dough. Expect options like gourmet sausage, roasted veggies, and specialty white pies that feel a step up from standard takeout. It’s worth planning a Coolville-to-Athens run when you want to make pizza the main event, not just a backup plan.
Big slices, a lively counter, and late-night energy just up the hill in uptown Athens.
Goodfellas is a classic walk-up slice shop, ideal when you’re in Athens for a game or show and want something quick without sacrificing flavor. The New York–style slices are wide, foldable, and crisp underneath, with toppings piled generously. It’s an easy detour for Coolville folks who like to combine errands in town with a casual pizza stop.
A long-running regional favorite where families share big pies after a day along the river.
This Belpre outpost of a regional staple feels familiar in the best way: red-check vibes, hot pans coming out of the oven, and a menu built around tried-and-true pies. The crust lands between thin and thick, sturdy enough for heavier toppings but still easy to polish off a few slices. It’s an appealing choice for Coolville families who don’t mind a short drive for a sit-down meal.
Hearty, cheesy pizzas with a thicker crust that travel well back to Coolville.
Smitty’s is built for carryout: generous portions, sturdy boxes, and pies that stay hot on the ride home. The crust runs thicker and more filling, with plenty of cheese and toppings that go right to the edge. When you’re loading up for a game night or feeding a crowd back in Coolville, this is a reliable stop to hit on your way out of Belpre.