01
Best in-village option
Hunt Brothers Pizza & Wings
In Corning • Gas-Station Carryout Counter • Quick-Stop Favorite
The easiest pizza fix right in Corning, with hot pies and wings ready when you are.
Tucked inside a convenience stop in the village, Hunt Brothers is where many Corning locals grab a pizza on their way home or while fueling up. The menu sticks to straightforward crowd-pleasers—think classic toppings, thick, cheesy slices, and crispy wings. It’s a practical, no-frills choice when you want something hot without leaving town.
02
Best for big groups
Fat Cat Pizza
New Lexington • Casual Hometown Pizzeria • Great For Teams And Families
A roomy New Lexington standby with hearty pizzas and plenty of space to gather.
Fat Cat Pizza is the kind of place where local teams pile in after a game and families linger over big, shareable pies. Crusts lean toward the hearty side, loaded up with generous toppings and ample cheese. Pair a couple of specialty pizzas with appetizers and you’ve got an easy, budget-friendly night out just a short drive from Corning.
03
Best road-trip detour
Cristy's Pizza
Somerset • Classic Regional Pizza Shop • Best For Customizable Pies
A well-known regional name offering build-it-your-way pizzas on a quick hop up the road in Somerset.
Cristy’s Pizza gives you that familiar small-chain consistency with plenty of room to customize your order. Thin, crisp-edged crust and a wide range of toppings make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s an ideal stop if you’re already heading through Somerset and want reliable pizza without slowing your day down.
04
Best sports-bar pizza
B&V's Snack Bar & Sports Grill
Crooksville • Lively Bar-And-Grill With Pizza • Game-Day Pick
A Crooksville hangout where you can catch the game and share a pizza and wings with friends.
B&V’s balances a neighborhood bar feel with a menu that goes well beyond typical bar snacks, including solid, shareable pizzas. Expect a crisp, golden crust and plenty of topping combinations, backed up by wings, sandwiches, and cold drinks. It’s especially popular on game nights, when the screens are on and the pizzas come out one after another.
05
Best small-town classic
Montell's Pizza
Glenford • Small-Town Takeout And Dine-In Spot • Local Favorite
A long-running Glenford pizzeria known for its comforting, old-school pies.
Montell’s feels like the kind of pizza shop every small town hopes to have: familiar, friendly, and consistent. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with a sauce that leans slightly sweet and a crust that holds up well to extra toppings. Call ahead for carryout on your way through Glenford, or sit down for a simple, relaxed meal after a day out in the countryside.