01
Best overall pick
Brothers Pizza and Restaurant
Central Cortland • Classic Family Pizzeria And Italian Spot • Local Favorite
A go-to Cortland mainstay serving classic pies with a friendly, small-town dining room feel.
Brothers is the kind of place where Cortland families meet after games and locals send out-of-towners when they ask where to get pizza. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and sturdy, with plenty of cheese and generous toppings that feel designed for sharing. It’s a reliable all-rounder: good for dine-in, carryout, and big orders when you’re feeding a crowd.
02
Best for hearty Italian-style pies
Cortland Belleria Restaurant
State Route 5 Corridor • Italian Restaurant With Robust Pizza Menu • Best For Groups And Variety
Thick, cheesy pizzas backed by a full Italian menu, ideal when not everyone at the table wants the same thing.
Cortland Belleria turns out hearty, sauce-forward pies that pair well with their pastas, wings, and subs. It’s a natural pick when you’ve got a mix of pizza devotees and non-pizza eaters in the same group, since the menu stretches well beyond the pie section. Expect a casual, family-friendly room, reliable carryout, and plenty of leftovers to take home.
03
Classic neighborhood staple
Vasilios Restaurant & Pizzeria
Trumbull Avenue Strip • Family Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Sit-Down Comfort
A homey Cortland staple where pizza shares the spotlight with diner-style comfort food.
Vasilios feels like a true town fixture: you can grab a solid pizza, but also breakfast plates, sandwiches, and classic comfort dishes. The pizza leans straightforward and customizable, with options like cauliflower crust for diners looking for something lighter. It’s especially good when you want a sit-down meal that still ends with a slice or two at the center of the table.
04
Best for quick takeout
Pizza Joe's Cortland
West Main Street • Regional Chain Pizzeria • Takeout And Game-Night Pick
A dependable regional chain offering crowd-pleasing pizzas, wings, and party trays for easy pickup.
Pizza Joe’s is built for busy weeknights and last-minute game-day spreads, with pizzas that travel well and a menu geared toward sharing. Crust, toppings, and sauces are dialed in to please a broad crowd rather than chase trends, which is exactly what many Cortland families want. If you’re ordering for a youth team, office lunch, or impromptu gathering, this is one of the simplest plays in town.
05
Best late-night and delivery option
Domino's Pizza
South High Street • National Delivery-Focused Chain • Delivery Workhorse
A familiar chain spot that anchors Cortland’s delivery scene with consistent pies and fast service.
Domino’s in Cortland hits the mark when convenience outranks everything else, from customizable pies to bread twists and wings arriving hot at your door. The menu is predictable in the best way, making it easy to satisfy picky eaters or large groups without overthinking it. It’s especially useful for late study sessions, casual movie nights, or those evenings when no one wants to cook or leave the house.