01
Best overall pick
Crowtown Pizza
Just Outside Downtown • Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
Crowtown Pizza feels like the kind of hometown shop where the crust is hearty, the toppings are generous, and the staff knows regulars by name.
This is the spot locals point to when you ask where they actually order their Friday-night pizza. The menu leans classic—think well-loaded pepperoni, meat lovers, and veggie pies—with enough variety to keep everyone at the table happy. Call ahead at busy times; it’s popular for both game nights and casual family dinners.
02
Top downtown slice
Pizza Point
Courthouse Square Area • Old-School Counter-Service Shop • Best For A Quick Slice
Pizza Point is a compact downtown shop that turns out straightforward, satisfying pies ideal for a casual lunch or low-key evening stop.
Set just off the heart of downtown, Pizza Point works well when you want good pizza without any fuss. The crust skews classic American—sturdy enough to hold plenty of cheese and toppings, but not overly heavy. It’s an easy choice if you’re exploring the historic district and want to grab a box to take back to your hotel or a nearby park.
03
Go-to for big groups
Plus 1 Pizza
Walnut Street Downtown • Local Takeout And Delivery Chain • Best For Big Orders
Plus 1 Pizza is a downtown standby with crowd-pleasing pies and combo deals that make feeding a group straightforward.
If you’re ordering for a team, a birthday, or a group of hungry friends, Plus 1 is built for that kind of night. The menu runs from classic pizzas to specialty combinations, with sides like breadsticks that round out a bigger order. It’s very much a takeout-and-delivery operation, so plan to enjoy it back at home, your rental, or a nearby gathering spot.
04
Best value specials
Creno's Pizza
Downtowner Plaza Shopping Strip • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Weeknight Takeout
Creno’s Pizza in Downtowner Plaza is a reliable choice for budget-friendly pies and frequent specials that work well for weeknights.
Tucked into one of Coshocton’s main shopping centers, Creno’s is convenient when you’re already running errands and want to leave with dinner sorted. Expect familiar styles—cheesy, well-sauced pizzas with classic toppings and a crust that holds up on the ride home. It’s especially handy for families looking to stretch their dollars without feeling like they compromised on taste.
05
Family-friendly chain pick
Pizza Hut
South 2Nd Street Commercial Strip • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Dine-In And Delivery Standby
Coshocton’s Pizza Hut offers the comfort of a familiar menu, with pan pizzas, wings, and pastas that work for mixed tastes at one table.
Located along one of the city’s main corridors, this Pizza Hut is a practical choice when you need something everyone recognizes. It’s good for families wanting a sit-down meal as well as groups who prefer to order in and keep things relaxed at home. Between customizable crusts, wings, and shareable sides, it covers most of the usual cravings in one stop.