01
Best overall pick
Boscoe’s Place
Downtown Covington • Modern Pub With Creative Pies • Local Favorite
Lively small-town spot serving inventive pizzas alongside a solid tap list.
Right on High Street, Boscoe’s feels like the kind of place every village wishes it had: a polished, comfortable pub that takes its pizza seriously. The menu leans into loaded specialty pies, with standouts like the buffalo chicken and a barbecue-inspired ‘Dad Bod’ that regulars rave about. It’s an easy pick for dinner with friends or a casual date night without leaving Covington.
02
Coziest small-town hangout
Y’all’s Country Club Pizza
North Covington • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Spot • Best For Families
Unpretentious, kid-friendly pizza joint where the focus is on generous toppings and friendly service.
Y’all’s Country Club Pizza feels like a throwback in the best way: simple booths, straightforward pies, and staff who quickly learn your usual order. The crust is classic small-town Ohio—sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, with the kind of edge you don’t leave on the plate. It’s the place locals lean on for team parties, easy Friday-night dinners, and big carryout orders when the whole crew is in town.
03
Classic sit-down pie
3 Joe’s Pizzeria & Trattoria
Downtown Piqua • Sit-Down Italian Pizzeria • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
A short drive from Covington, 3 Joe’s pairs hand-tossed pizzas with a full lineup of Italian comfort food.
Set in the heart of downtown Piqua, 3 Joe’s is the kind of place where you can make a night of it rather than just grabbing a box to go. Pizzas come out with a nicely chewy crust and plenty of topping combinations, from simple pepperoni to more dressed-up specialty options. Add in pastas, salads, and a glass of wine, and it’s a solid choice when you want a sit-down meal instead of quick takeout.
04
Most iconic regional pie
Marion’s Piazza – Troy
South Of Covington In Troy • Retro Dayton-Style Pizza Parlor • Big-Group Pick
Beloved regional chain known for ultra-thin, square-cut pizzas loaded edge-to-edge with toppings.
The Troy location of Marion’s makes Dayton-style pizza an easy option from Covington, and it’s worth the short drive. Expect a big, open dining room that can handle teams, birthdays, and family gatherings without feeling cramped. The crust is thin and crisp, the toppings are chopped fine and spread to every corner, and the format is perfect for sharing a few different pies with a crowd.
05
Best grab-and-go classic
Cassano’s Pizza King – Piqua
East Of Covington In Piqua • Old-School Carryout Joint • Game-Night Standby
Regional favorite for thin, crunchy-crust pizza that tastes like classic Dayton nostalgia in a box.
Cassano’s in Piqua is a go-to when you want that unmistakable Dayton-style flavor without fuss. The crust skews cracker-thin, the sauce leans savory, and the toppings go right to the edge, making every square-cut piece feel like a corner slice. It’s ideal for quick carryout or delivery when you’re stocking up for a game, movie night, or a laid-back evening at home in Covington.