01
Best lakefront pick
Castaway Craig's Pub & Grub
Craig Beach Lakefront • Lively Lakefront Pub With Pizza And Bar Bites • Best Overall Pick
Beachy vibes, cold drinks, and shareable pizzas just steps from the sand.
Castaway Craig's is the spot people think of when they picture grabbing a bite right at Craig Beach, with a casual, come-as-you-are feel. The pizzas lean hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings that pair well with a beer after a day on the water. It is an easy choice when you want to stay close to the lake and still get a satisfying pie.
02
Closest classic pizzeria
Lake Milton Pizza
Lake Milton • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Takeout
A straightforward local pizza shop turning out hot, cheesy pies ideal for takeout to the lake.
Lake Milton Pizza has the familiar feel of a small-town pizza joint, with a menu built around reliable, well-loaded pies. Crusts are sturdy enough to hold up in the box, which makes this a smart move for grabbing dinner on your way back to a rental or campsite. Expect friendly, quick service and pizza that tastes exactly like the kind locals grow up on.
03
Mahoning Valley legend
Wedgewood Pizza Austintown
Austintown • Thick-Crust Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Classic
Iconic, pan-baked Youngstown-style pizza that many locals will tell you is the best around.
If you ask serious pizza fans near Craig Beach where they drive for a great pie, Wedgewood in Austintown comes up fast. The crust is thick but airy, with crisp edges, and the shop is known for generous, edge-to-edge toppings and bold, slightly sweet sauce. It is a bit of a drive from the lake, but one tray here easily feeds a group back at the cabin.
04
Old-school Italian option
Belleria Pizza Austintown
Austintown • Family Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Families
Red-sauce Italian comfort food with pizzas that please both kids and longtime locals.
Belleria brings a sit-down Italian feel, so it works well when your group wants pizza but also pasta, salads, and a few comfort-food classics. The pizzas lean traditional, with a medium crust, ample cheese, and familiar topping combos that are easy to share. It is a relaxed, family-friendly choice if you are out running errands in Austintown and want to turn it into a proper meal.
05
Local sports-night spot
Bruno Brothers Pizza
Austintown • Casual Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Best For Game Nights
Generous pies, wings, and a laid-back atmosphere that fits perfectly with a game on TV.
Bruno Brothers is the kind of place where you order a couple of large pizzas, some wings, and settle in to watch a game with friends. The pies are substantial, with plenty of cheese and topping coverage, and the crust stays sturdy enough for fold-and-bite eating. For groups coming in from Craig Beach looking to stretch an evening off the water, it is an easy, low-pressure hangout.