01
Best in-town convenience
Domino's Pizza
West Main Street, Crooksville • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Chain carryout and delivery spot right in Crooksville turning out consistently hot, customizable pies for busy weeknights.[1]
If you want pizza without leaving the village limits, this is the go-to. The menu leans on build-your-own and specialty pizzas, plus wings and sandwiches for mixed groups. It’s especially handy for late games or last-minute family dinners when you just need something fast and reliable.
02
Classic sit-down Italian
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Old-School Italian Pizzeria And Pasta House • Local Favorite For Dine-In
Beloved Zanesville institution known for saucy, cheese-loaded pies and a cozy, old-school dining room.
Many Crooksville locals are happy to make the short drive to Adornetto's when they want pizza to feel like a proper night out. Expect a crowd-pleasing menu with thickly topped pizzas, hearty red-sauce pastas, and garlic bread that disappears fast. It’s the place you choose when grandparents, kids, and out-of-town guests are all at the same table.
03
Best for big groups
Wally's Pizza
North Zanesville • Family Pizza Shop With Generous Portions • Great For Teams And Parties
Hearty, shareable pies with plenty of toppings make this a go-to for teams, birthday parties, and casual meetups.
Wally's leans into the classic Ohio pizza-shop vibe: big pies, lots of cheese, and no fuss. The crust strikes a middle ground between soft and crisp, built to hold serious toppings without getting soggy. If you’re hauling a carload of kids after a tournament or need to feed a crowd on a budget, it fits the bill.
04
Family-friendly chain stop
Pizza Hut
New Lexington Commercial Strip • Casual National Pizza Chain • Best For Families
Familiar pan and stuffed-crust pizzas in a family-friendly setting just a short drive from Crooksville.
When you want something everyone recognizes, the Pizza Hut in New Lexington is an easy choice. Kids can stick with classics like pepperoni pan pizza while adults mix in wings, pasta, or a thin-and-crispy pie. It’s a practical option for weeknight dinners or post-practice stops when no one feels like cooking.
05
Crispy thin-crust pick
Donatos Pizza
East Zanesville • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Crispy Thin Crust
Ohio-born chain known for edge-to-edge toppings on a crispy, square-cut thin crust.
If you like your pizza crackly and cut into squares, Donatos is worth the drive. The crust stays crisp under generous, finely chopped toppings, and the edge-to-edge coverage means every piece feels like a ‘good’ slice. It’s a smart choice for takeout when you want something lighter than heavy pan pizza but still big on flavor.