01
Classic hometown favorite
Lorobi's Pizza
Downtown Gallipolis Riverfront • Old-School Square-Cut Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
A Gallipolis institution serving crisp, square-cut pies that locals grow up on and keep coming back for.
Lorobi's leans into that classic southeastern Ohio style: thin, edge-to-edge toppings, plenty of cheese, and a crust that stays crisp under a heavy load. It is the place people suggest first for team parties, after-game slices, or when you want the closest thing to a 'this is what we ate growing up' experience.
02
Best for big groups
P.J.'s Pizza
Gallipolis Side Streets Near Downtown • Casual Delivery-And-Carryout Joint • Game-Day Staple
Hearty, topping-loaded pizzas and big trays of sides make this a go-to when you are feeding a crowd.
P.J.'s is all about generous portions and straightforward, classic pies that hold up well for takeout or delivery. People lean on it for football Saturdays, birthday gatherings, and those nights when cooking for a house full of relatives sounds like too much work.
03
Cozy dine-in choice
Tuscany Italian Restaurant
Jackson Pike Shopping Corridor In Gallipolis • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Lingering Dinners
A sit-down spot where you can pair a hand-tossed pizza with pasta, salad, and a slow, unhurried meal.
Tuscany is where locals go when they want pizza but also want to linger over bread, salad, and conversation. The pies come out with a softer, hand-tossed crust and plenty of classic toppings, making it an easy pick for mixed groups who want more than just a quick slice.
04
Family-friendly standby
Giovanni's Pizza (Proctorville)
Proctorville Strip Along State Route 7 • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Best For Families
Reliable, kid-approved pies, subs, and sides just down the road in Proctorville.
Giovanni's in Proctorville offers that familiar regional-chain comfort: consistent pizzas, plenty of toppings, and a menu broad enough to keep everyone at the table happy. It is an easy stop on the way home along the river, especially when you want something that will please both picky kids and hungry adults.
05
Cross-river crowd-pleaser
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti House (Lesage)
Across The River In Lesage, West Virginia • Laid-Back West Virginia Pizza-And-Pasta Spot • Cross-River Favorite
A short hop over into West Virginia brings you to chewy-crust pies and classic red-sauce comfort food.
Gino's in Lesage is a handy option when you do not mind crossing the river for dinner or carryout. The pizza leans on a slightly thicker, chewy base with plenty of sauce, and the spaghetti and subs make it a flexible stop when not everyone in the group is in a pizza-only mood.