01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage
Downtown Cambridge • Lively Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A busy Cambridge staple known for generous toppings, a big menu, and friendly small-town service.
Pizza Cottage is often the first name locals throw out when you ask where to get pizza in Cambridge. The crust is sturdy enough to hold a heavy load of toppings, and their specialty pies and cheesy garlic bread are easy crowd-pleasers. It works just as well for a family dinner after a day at The Wilds as it does for a quick carryout order on your way back to Cumberland.
02
Classic hometown slice
Wally's Pizza
South Cambridge • Old-School Pizza Parlor • Best For Classic Pies
A no-frills spot that focuses on crisp, classic pies with a loyal local following.
Wally's Pizza feels like the kind of small-town shop that has been feeding teams and families for years. Expect a straightforward menu, thin-to-medium crust, and plenty of cheese, with sizes that work well for sharing. It is a comfortable option when you want a traditional pie without any fuss or trendy toppings.
03
Worth-the-drive carryout
Plus One Pizza
Byesville • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Takeout
A Guernsey County standby with customizable pies and hefty toppings, ideal for call-ahead pickup.
Plus One Pizza in Byesville is a popular choice when you want to phone in a pie, swing through, and head back home with dinner in the box. They lean into well-loaded pizzas, from meat-heavy options to veggie builds, plus wings and sides to round out the order. For Cumberland residents, it is an easy stop when you are already headed toward I-77 or Cambridge.
04
Reliable chain option
Domino's Pizza
Near I-70 In Cambridge • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
Fast, consistent pizza with app-based ordering and late-night delivery that reaches much of the area around Cambridge.
When you need something predictable and quick, the Cambridge Domino's is the go-to chain answer. The menu covers pizzas, sandwiches, pastas, and wings, and the online deals can be a good value when you are feeding a group. It is especially handy if you are staying near the interstate or rolling back into town later in the evening.
05
Dine-in chain comfort
Pizza Hut
New Concord • Casual Dine-In Chain • Best For Families
A familiar sit-down option for pan pizza, breadsticks, and salads just up the road in New Concord.
If you grew up with red-roof Pizza Hut memories, the New Concord location delivers that same booth-and-pan-pizza comfort. It is an easy meeting spot for families coming from different directions, with plenty of kid-friendly choices and shareable starters. The short drive from Cumberland makes it a practical choice when you want a simple, sit-down meal rather than takeout.