01
Best overall pick
Dino's Pizza
Oregon – Navarre Avenue Corridor • Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria • Go-To For East Side Regulars
A long-running Oregon staple turning out hearty, sauce-forward pies that feel built for game nights and family gatherings.
Dino's hits that sweet spot between old-school and approachable, with crust that's sturdy enough for generous toppings and a sauce locals swear by. It’s the kind of place where a large pepperoni and a chef salad can feed a crew without breaking the bank. Call ahead for weekend nights—curbside boxes tend to stack up fast.
02
Best for carryout from Curtice
J-Cups Pizza
Oregon – East Side • Takeout-Focused Pizza Shop • Reliable Weeknight Standby
A no-frills Oregon favorite known for consistent pies, generous cheese, and quick turnaround on carryout orders.
J-Cups is a practical choice when you’re driving in from Curtice and just want hot pizza without a lot of ceremony. The crust leans on the thicker side of hand-tossed, making it great for loaded specialty pies and meat-heavy combos. Add an order of breadsticks and you’ve got an easy dinner for a boat crew or a backyard hangout.
03
Best for a night out
Home Slice Pizza
Downtown Toledo – Warehouse District • Lively Bar-Style Pizzeria • Pre-Game And Late-Night Favorite
Creative slices, a solid draft list, and a buzzy downtown setting make this a fun upgrade from your usual delivery pie.
Home Slice is the spot when you’re ready to trade the marina parking lot for a night in the city. Expect foldable New York–leaning slices, interesting topping combos, and the option to linger over a pint upstairs. It’s an easy add-on to a Mud Hens game or a concert at nearby venues, especially if you like splitting a couple of large pizzas with a group.
04
Best classic Toledo-style
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti House
West Toledo – Monroe Street • Old-School Pizza And Pasta Joint • Classic Red-Sauce Institution
A Toledo mainstay with crispy-edged pies, plenty of cheese, and the kind of red-sauce comfort that keeps generations coming back.
Gino’s is worth the extra drive from Curtice if you like your pizza with a bit of nostalgia. The crust is thin but sturdy, with a light crunch around the edges and a good balance of sauce to cheese. Pair a pizza with a shared bowl of spaghetti or lasagna and you’ve got a proper sit-down meal instead of just a quick slice.
05
Best for craft and college-town energy
Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar
West Toledo – University Of Toledo Area • Craft Pizza Bar • Best For Groups And Craft Beer
Modern, college-adjacent pizza bar turning out chewy, blistered-crust pies alongside a strong beer list.
Stubborn Brother leans more toward the artisan side, with pizzas that show off good dough, careful baking, and toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. It draws a mix of students, families, and beer nerds, so the room has a lively, casual buzz. If you’re coming from Curtice for a game or event near campus, this is an easy pre- or post-stop that still feels distinctly local.