Custar • best pizza

5 Best Pizzerias & Pizza Places for Custar Ohio

Custar is a quiet village, but you are only a short country drive from some of northwest Ohio’s most dependable pizza. Most locals point their car toward Bowling Green when cravings hit, where campus classics and low-key parlors turn out pies late into the evening. This list focuses on reliable, real-world favorites that people around Custar actually order from, whether it is for a Friday night in or a post-game slice.

View List Contact Us

01 Best overall pick

Campus Pollyeyes

Near Bgsu Campus In Bowling Green • Lively College-Town Pizzeria Known For Stuffed Breadsticks • Local Favorite For Big Appetites

A Bowling Green institution where massive pizzas and famous stuffed breadsticks are built to feed a hungry crowd.

If you ask BGSU grads where to grab pizza, Campus Pollyeyes is usually the first name you hear. The pies are hearty with plenty of cheese, but the real draw is the chewy, buttery stuffed breadsticks that travel well back to Custar. Call ahead on busy nights, especially during school year weekends, because orders stack up fast.

02 Best classic carryout

Pisanello's Pizza

Downtown Bowling Green • Classic Midwest Pizzeria With A Cozy Small-Town Feel • Best For Families

Old-school pizza with generous toppings and familiar flavors that make it an easy family favorite.

Pisanello's feels like the kind of place you grew up ordering from: soft, doughy crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward topping combos. It is a nice middle ground spot when you are feeding kids, grandparents, and everyone in between. Order a couple of large pies and a salad, then head back toward Custar before the cheese cools.

03 Best for a night out

Pizza Pub 516

Central Bowling Green • Casual Pub With Creative Pizzas And A Full Bar • Best For Game Nights And Groups

A laid-back pub where you can pair craft beers with shareable pizzas loaded up with toppings.

Pizza Pub 516 is the move when you want more than just takeout and do not mind the drive into town. The crust is crispier and the toppings more adventurous than a basic delivery chain, with plenty of options for meat lovers and veggie eaters alike. Grab a table, catch a game on TV, and then roll back to Custar after a couple of slices and a drink.

04 Most reliable late-night delivery

Domino's Pizza (Bowling Green)

East Side Of Bowling Green • National Delivery Chain With Customizable Pies • Best For Late-Night Convenience

A go-to when you need predictable, quick pizza with lots of crust, sauce, and topping options.

Thanks to the college crowd, the Bowling Green Domino's stays busy and used to handling late orders and special requests. The online ordering makes it easy to time a pickup on your way back through town from errands or a game. It is not the most romantic pizza in Ohio, but it is fast, consistent, and open later than most mom-and-pop spots.

05 Best for pan pizza cravings

Pizza Hut (Bowling Green)

North Side Of Bowling Green • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain With Pan And Stuffed-Crust Options • Best For Familiar Comfort Pizza

A dependable stop when you are in the mood for thick, buttery pan crust and classic chain-style pies.

Bowling Green’s Pizza Hut hits that nostalgic spot if you grew up on personal pans and red-checkered tables. The pan and stuffed-crust pizzas hold heat well, which matters when you are hauling dinner back toward Custar. It is a smart pick for simple, crowd-pleasing orders when nobody wants to argue about the menu.