01
Best overall pick
Twisted Tomato Pizzeria
Portage Trail Area • Creative Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Specialty Pies
A go-to spot for well-topped, flavor-forward pizzas that still feel like comfort food.
Twisted Tomato leans into generous toppings and fun combinations without losing the basics—crispy crust, good sauce, and cheese that stretches. It’s the kind of place locals call on a weeknight when they want something better than standard delivery but still easy. Expect friendly counter service, plenty of shareable pies, and solid wings and sides to round out an order.
02
Classic family joint
Emidio's Pizza
State Road Corridor • Old-School Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Family Meals
A longtime State Road fixture serving hearty, classic pies alongside pastas and other Italian comfort dishes.
Emidio’s feels like the kind of place that has been feeding local teams and families for decades, with big portions and a familiar, no-rush dining room. The pizza leans traditional—think sturdy crust, ample cheese, and crowd-pleasing toppings that work well for groups. It’s an easy choice when you want a full dinner out, not just a quick slice on the go.
03
Neighborhood staple
Mark and Philly Pizza
Bailey Road Neighborhood • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Takeout Night
A long-running mom-and-pop shop known for reliable takeout pies that locals grow up on.
Mark and Philly keeps things straightforward—solid dough, a slightly sweeter sauce, and toppings piled like they remember you asked for extra. It’s the kind of place where regulars have a favorite order and stick with it for years. Call ahead, swing by to grab your boxes, and you’re set for an easy pizza night at home.
04
Dependable chain option
Jet's Pizza
Hudson Drive Retail Strip • Detroit-Style And Round Pizza Chain • Best For Thick, Cheesy Square Pies
A popular stop for Jet’s signature crispy-edged deep-dish squares and late-night-friendly delivery.
This Hudson Drive outpost is especially known for its Detroit-style pan pizzas, with airy dough, caramelized cheese at the edges, and bold topping options. It’s practical for game days or group orders when people want something filling and familiar. Customize the crust style and flavor, add a salad or bread, and you can feed a crowd without much planning.
05
Worth-the-drive favorite
Altieri's Pizza
Short Drive To Stow • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best Nearby Spot For Square-Cut Party Pizza
A beloved Stow mainstay turning out thin, square-cut pies that many Falls locals happily drive for.
Altieri’s has that nostalgic, slightly crunchy crust and edge-to-edge topping style that works perfectly for sharing with a group. Order a large cut into party squares and it disappears fast at gatherings, from birthdays to casual Friday nights. It’s just a few minutes up the road, but it’s firmly in the rotation for many Cuyahoga Falls pizza fans.