01
Best overall pick
Kellione's Pizza
Waverly Strip Along Us-23 • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Carryout
A Pike County standby, Kellione's turns out crispy-edged pies with plenty of toppings and dependable service.
If you ask around Cynthiana for a go-to pizza place, Kellione's is the name you hear most often. The crust walks a nice line between crisp and chewy, and the toppings run generous without getting greasy. It is the kind of small-town shop where a large pepperoni and a side of breadsticks can easily feed a family on a weeknight.
02
Best for classic Ohio-style
Cardo's Pizza of Waverly
Downtown Waverly • Laid-Back Regional Chain • Best For Familiar Flavors
Cardo's serves the kind of thin, edge-to-edge Ohio pizza many locals grew up on, with a straightforward menu that is easy to order from.
Cardo's is ideal when you want that nostalgic Ohio-style pie: a thinner crust, lots of cheese, and toppings spread all the way to the edge. The dining room is simple but friendly, and it handles everything from quick lunches to team celebrations without fuss. It is also a solid option if you are ordering several large pizzas for a crowd back in Cynthiana.
03
Best for family dinners
Giovanni's Pizza Waverly
East Waverly Neighborhood • Family Italian And Pizza Joint • Best For Groups And Kids
Giovanni's pairs hearty pizzas with pastas and subs, making it a flexible choice when not everyone in the group wants the same thing.
This is the spot to choose when you have a car full of hungry kids or a mixed group that wants more than just pizza. Pies come with a soft, bready crust and plenty of cheese, and there are enough sides and pasta dishes to round out a full sit-down meal. It is close enough to Cynthiana for an easy evening out without feeling like a trek.
04
Best pizza-and-wings combo
Racks Sports Bar & Grill
Waverly, Near The River • Lively Sports Bar With Pizza • Best Game-Day Stop
Racks is a casual sports bar where locals pair shareable pizzas with wings, cold drinks, and whatever game is on TV.
If you want pizza with a side of atmosphere, Racks fits the bill. The pies are straightforward but satisfying, especially when you add an order of wings and settle in to catch a game. It is more of a hangout than a dedicated pizzeria, but for many Cynthiana locals, this is the place to meet friends, split a pizza, and stay awhile.
05
Worth-the-drive small-town spot
Lorisa's Pizza
Bainbridge Village Center • Old-School Hometown Pizza Shop • Best Small-Town Detour
A short country drive from Cynthiana, Lorisa's rewards you with well-baked pies and a friendly, everyone-knows-you vibe.
Lorisa's feels like the kind of place that anchors a small village: no frills, just solid pizza and familiar faces. The crust has a nice bite, the sauce leans savory, and the staff treats regulars and first-timers the same. It is an easy detour if you are already heading west from Cynthiana and want a low-key dinner that still feels like an outing.