01
Best overall pick
Kraus' Pizza – Dalton Lincoln View
Dalton – Lincoln View Area • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria And Carryout • Local Standby For Game Night
Beloved for its cheesy, square-cut pies and reliable carryout, this is the Dalton go-to when everyone just wants Kraus for dinner.
The Dalton Lincoln View Kraus’ location feels like the community’s default choice for pizza night, with a steady stream of locals picking up orders. Expect the signature Kraus style: a slightly sweet sauce, plenty of cheese, and toppings spread all the way to the edge of the pan. Add in wings, subs, and salads, and it’s easy to cover everyone’s favorites with a single stop.
02
Best for a countryside detour
Kidron Pizza Company
Kidron – South Of Dalton • Takeout-Focused Country Pizzeria • Great After A Day In Amish Country
A cozy Kidron staple turning out hearty, no-nonsense pizzas that pair perfectly with a drive through the countryside.
Just a few minutes south of Dalton, Kidron Pizza fits right in with the town’s laid-back, rural feel. The menu is straightforward but well-executed, with generously topped pies and classic sides that travel well. It’s a natural stop after browsing local shops and farm stands, or anytime you want a low-key takeout pizza that tastes homemade.
03
Worth-the-drive classic
Coccia House
Wooster – West Of Downtown • Old-School Italian Pizza House • Iconic Sit-Down Pizza Experience
A Wooster institution famous for loaded, pan-style pies that many locals consider the best pizza in the county.
Coccia House has been drawing pizza fans to Wooster for decades, and it’s the kind of place Dalton-area residents happily drive for. The pizzas are hearty and distinctive, with a thicker crust, generous layers of cheese, and toppings piled high in true Ohio style. The cozy, lived-in dining room and unhurried pace make it a great choice when you want to make a night of it rather than just grab a quick box to go.
04
Best for big-group orders
East of Chicago Pizza – Orrville
Downtown Orrville • Casual Regional Chain Pizzeria • Go-To For Variety And Value
A flexible option with pan, thin, and deep-dish pies plus wings and subs, ideal when you are feeding a crowd from Dalton or Orrville.
Orrville’s East of Chicago gives you a lot of ways to build a pizza, from thick and doughy pan crusts to lighter thin-crust options. The menu runs deep with specialty pies, build-your-own combinations, wings, and sandwiches, which makes it a solid pick for church groups, teams, and family gatherings. Order ahead for pickup on your way through town, or mix a couple of different styles if you’ve got picky eaters in the group.
05
Best for late-night cravings
Kraus' Pizza – Massillon Amherst Road
Massillon – Amherst Road Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza And Wings Joint • Popular Carryout With Extended Hours
This busy Massillon outpost of Kraus’ is known for edge-to-edge toppings, crispy crust, and hours that work for later dinners.
If you are on the east side of Dalton or already headed toward Massillon, the Amherst Road Kraus’ is a dependable option that stays open later on weekends. The pies mirror what fans love across the chain: plenty of toppings, a signature sauce, and that distinctive square cut that is easy to share. Round out the order with fried chicken, jojo potatoes, or wings and you have a full comfort-food spread for a long evening in.