01
Best overall pick
Jersey Girls Pizzeria Danville
Central Danville • Boardwalk-Style Pizzeria And Diner • Local Favorite
A Jersey-shore-inspired spot in the heart of town serving hearty pies alongside classic comfort food.
Jersey Girls brings a bit of boardwalk flair to Market Street, with generously topped pizzas that feel substantial without being fussy. It is the kind of place where you can grab a casual supper after a ballgame, share a couple of specialty pies, and still have room for dessert. Regulars appreciate the friendly staff, reliable takeout, and the fact that it is an easy walk from much of the village.
02
Best for carryout
Spin City Pizza
Progress Drive, Danville • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Quick And Convenient Pick
A straightforward, no-nonsense pizza shop known for hot pies, generous toppings, and smooth carryout service.
Tucked along Progress Drive, Spin City Pizza is built for busy locals who want a quality pie without a long wait. The menu leans classic, with crowd-pleasers like pepperoni, deluxe, and meat lovers, plus enough specialty options to keep things interesting. It is a handy stop on the way home from work or after a day on the Kokosing Gap Trail when you just want to grab a box and relax at home.
03
Best college-town vibe
The Village Inn
Gambier Near Kenyon College • Casual Sit-Down Restaurant And Bar • Best For Lingering Over A Pie
A relaxed Gambier hangout where pizzas share the spotlight with pub fare, craft beer, and a steady buzz of college-town energy.
The Village Inn sits right in Kenyon College country, so expect a mix of students, faculty, and locals sharing pizzas and pitchers. The crust is sturdy enough for lots of toppings, and the menu balances classic combinations with more creative options that suit a longer, sit-down meal. It is an easy choice when you want to turn pizza night into a proper evening out with conversation and a couple of drinks.
04
Best for big groups
Donatos Pizza
Coshocton Avenue, Mount Vernon • Thin-Crust Ohio-Based Chain • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
A familiar thin-crust favorite known for edge-to-edge toppings and an easy ordering experience for families and teams.
On Coshocton Avenue in Mount Vernon, Donatos is a natural stop when you are feeding a crowd and need something everyone will agree on. The trademark thin crust, loaded with toppings all the way to the edge, makes it easy to order several large pies and let people sample different flavors. With wings, salads, and subs on the menu, it works just as well for a team party as for a quick weeknight dinner.
05
Classic hometown slice
Dirko's Pizza
Downtown Mount Vernon • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Best Nostalgic Pick
A long-running local shop serving hearty, no-frills pies that taste like small-town pizza should.
Dirko's feels like the kind of pizzeria every Ohio town used to have: simple booths, a warm oven, and a focus on well-made dough, sauce, and cheese. The pizzas lean hearty, with a crust that can handle extra cheese and plenty of toppings, making it a solid option if you like your slice on the filling side. It is especially popular with locals who grew up on it and still swing by when they are back in Mount Vernon.