01
Best overall pick
Tammy's Pizza
Grove City Town Center • Classic Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cornerstone Grove City shop doing hearty, edge-to-edge toppings on crisp, square-cut pies.
Tammy's feels like the place everyone in Grove City has a story about, from kids’ team parties to low-key Friday nights. The crust is classic Columbus-style—thin but sturdy, with toppings spread all the way to the edge and a generous hand with the cheese. It’s an easy go-to when you want a reliable pie that tastes like the local standard rather than a generic chain pizza.
02
Old-school tavern pies
Plank's on Broadway
Historic Broadway Strip • Tavern-Style Bar And Pizza Joint • Best For Thin-Crust And A Beer
A historic Broadway bar turning out caramelized-cheese, tavern-cut pizzas that pair perfectly with a cold draft.
Plank's is the kind of wood-paneled, slightly noisy spot where the pizza has as much character as the regulars at the bar. Expect a thin, slightly sweet crust, plenty of crispy cheese at the edges, and toppings that lean classic—pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and the like. It’s an easy choice when you want a proper sit-down pizza night with a couple of drinks and a game on in the background.
03
Neighborhood standby
Grandstand Pizza Shop
Side Streets Just Off Broadway • No-Frills Carryout And Dine-In Shop • Best For Quick Family Takeout
A straightforward local shop known for generous portions, friendly service, and crowd-pleasing pies.
Grandstand keeps things simple in the best way: solid dough, well-seasoned sauce, and toppings that don’t feel skimpy. The menu leans toward family comfort food—think classic pepperoni, meat-lovers, and loaded veggie pizzas, plus a few pastas and wings for good measure. It’s the place you call when everyone’s hungry, nobody wants to cook, and you need a couple of big boxes on the table in short order.
04
Game-day crowd pleaser
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Neighborhood Strip Near Residential Parks • Casual Pizza And Subs Joint • Best For Big Groups And Delivery
A local mini-chain slinging thick and thin pies, wings, and subs that are built to feed a crowd.
Flyers is tailor-made for game days and neighborhood gatherings, with pizza sizes and combo deals that make ordering for a group painless. The crust options range from classic thin to heartier pan styles, and the sauce has a mild sweetness that works especially well with pepperoni and extra cheese. Add in wings, breadsticks, and subs, and you can cover just about every craving with a single delivery order.
05
Reliable chain favorite
Donatos Pizza
Stringtown Road Retail Corridor • Columbus-Born Pizza Chain • Best For Consistent, Crispy Thin Crust
A Columbus classic offering ultra-thin crust pizzas cut in neat squares with edge-to-edge toppings.
Donatos may be a regional chain, but around southwest Franklin County it still feels like a hometown staple. The draw is the signature ultra-thin crust and almost obsessively even layer of toppings, so every square has the same satisfying cheese-and-crunch ratio. It’s a smart pick when you want something fast, predictable, and easy to grab while you’re already running errands along Stringtown Road.