01
Classic neighborhood standby
Jacobs Pizza
Day Heights Along State Route 131 • No-Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Local Weeknight Go-To
Tight, hometown shop turning out generous, crowd-pleasing pies that quietly anchor pizza night in Day Heights.[1]
Right on Route 131, Jacobs Pizza is the spot many Day Heights residents lean on when they want something easy and reliably good without driving into Milford or the city.[1] The menu sticks to familiar territory—pepperoni-heavy pies, loaded supremes, and cheesy bread—but portions are hearty and prices are friendly. Call ahead on busy evenings and be ready to grab your boxes and head home; this place is about fast, friendly carryout over frills.[1]
02
Best wood-fired pies
Joe's Pizza Napoli
Milford Off Chamber Drive • Neapolitan-Style Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Purists
Milford favorite specializing in blistered, airy-crusted pies baked hot and fast in a Neapolitan-style oven.[5]
Tucked just off Chamber Drive in Milford, Joe's Pizza Napoli draws pizza fans from well beyond Clermont County for its soft, leopard-spotted crusts and balanced toppings.[5] The menu leans Italian with simple combinations—think quality mozzarella, fresh basil, and good olive oil—alongside a few more inventive specials. It’s the place you pick when you care as much about the dough and bake as you do about the toppings, and you don’t mind waiting a bit for something made with care.[5]
03
Lively downtown option
Padrino
Historic Downtown Milford • Casual Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Date Nights
Brick-walled downtown Milford spot that balances serious pizza with a full Italian menu and a lively small-town Main Street vibe.[5]
Set on Main Street in historic downtown Milford, Padrino feels like the social hub for pizza, pasta, and drinks before or after a stroll down to the riverfront.[5] Pizzas range from straightforward pepperoni to more dressed-up specialty pies, and you can round things out with appetizers, salads, and a good selection of tap beers. It’s an easy choice when you’re meeting friends or want a date-night setting that still feels relaxed and local.[5]
04
Old-school carryout classic
Angilo's Pizza on Route 131
Route 131 Between Day Heights And Milford • Cincinnati-Style Pizza & Hoagie Shop • Best For Nostalgic Flavors
Long-running Route 131 mainstay that locals praise as one of the area’s original pizza spots, serving thin pies and hearty hoagies with a retro feel.[1]
Angilo's on Route 131 has been around long enough that many Day Heights and Milford families grew up on its pizza, and it still gets mentioned as one of the first real pizza joints in the area.[1] Expect a straightforward, slightly thinner crust, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings, plus big, saucy hoagies that make it a popular takeout choice. It’s the kind of place you go when you’re craving that specific old-school Cincinnati-style flavor you remember from childhood.[1]
05
Worth-the-drive Detroit-style
TAGLIO Bar + Pizzeria
Columbia-Tusculum, East Cincinnati • Detroit-Style Craft Pizzeria & Bar • Best For Craft Pies And Drinks
East-side hot spot known for its golden, crispy-edged Detroit-style squares and creative toppings, an easy drive in from Day Heights when you want something different.[4][5]
If you’re up for a short hop toward the city, TAGLIO’s Columbia-Tusculum location is a favorite for thick, caramelized-edge Detroit-style pizza with big, modern flavors.[4][5] Square pans, bold topping combinations, and a good beer and cocktail list make it feel more like a night out than a simple pizza stop. It’s a smart pick when you’ve done the local carryout circuit and want to make an evening of trying something that regularly shows up on ‘best pizza’ lists around Cincinnati.[4][5]