01
Best overall pick
DiAngelo's Pizza
Cadiz • Family-Run Italian Spot • Local Favorite For Hearty Pies
Classic, generously topped pizzas and Italian comfort food make this Cadiz mainstay worth the short drive from Deersville.
DiAngelo's is the spot people in the Tappan Lake and Deersville area point to when they want a sit-down pizza night. The pies are substantial without feeling fussy, and the same kitchen turns out pastas, subs, and salads that cover everyone at the table. It is a comfortable, unpretentious choice when you want a proper meal, not just a quick slice.
02
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Cadiz Town Center • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Takeout
For fast, predictable pizza and wings, the Cadiz Domino's is the go-to delivery option around Deersville.
If you are renting a cabin or staying near the lake and just want something hot delivered, the Cadiz Domino's is the practical choice. Online ordering, frequent specials, and a wide range of toppings make it easy to feed a group without overthinking it. It is also handy for late-night cravings when the smaller mom-and-pop shops have closed.
03
Old-school favorite
Pangrazio's Pizza
Dennison/Uhrichsville • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For Sharing With A Group
A long-running local shop known for crowd-pleasing pies that travel well back to the lake.
Pangrazio's has that lived-in, old-school feel that tells you it has been a local staple for years. The pizzas lean toward classic toppings and generous cheese, built for sharing with family or a carload of friends. Order a couple of larges and you will have plenty to bring back to Deersville or your campsite for later snacking.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Ianni's Pizzeria
New Philadelphia • Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For A Sit-Down Pizza Night
New Philadelphia's Ianni's rewards the extra drive with well-balanced pies and a cozy, no-rush dining room.
If you are already heading toward New Philadelphia for shopping or errands, planning dinner at Ianni's is an easy call. The pizzas strike a nice balance between crispness and chew, with toppings that feel thoughtfully layered rather than piled on. The relaxed, family-friendly room makes it a comfortable spot to linger over a pitcher of soda and a couple of specialty pies.
05
Best pizza with a beer
Dennison Yard
Dennison Depot District • Casual Pub And Pizza Spot • Best For Pizza And A Pint
Set in a converted rail-side building, Dennison Yard serves satisfying pizzas alongside a solid tap list.
Dennison Yard is where locals go when they want pizza with a bit more atmosphere than a typical takeout joint. The setting, tied to the town's railroad history, gives it a sense of place that pairs nicely with a cold beer and a hot pie. It works just as well for a casual date night as it does for relaxing after a day on the water at Tappan Lake.