01
Best overall pick
MOHIO Pizza Co
Historic Downtown Delaware • Wood-Fired Pizzeria And Bar • Local Favorite
Creative wood-fired pies and a lively downtown vibe make MOHIO an easy first choice for pizza night.
Set right on Sandusky Street, MOHIO leans into blistered, wood-fired crusts topped with seasonal ingredients and fun flavor combinations. The space feels polished but relaxed, so it works as well for date night as it does for a casual bite with friends before a show or a game. If you like to linger, pair a specialty pie with a local beer and watch downtown Delaware roll by outside the front windows.
02
Best by-the-slice stop
Shorty’s Pizza
West Central Avenue • New York–Inspired Slice Shop • Quick Bite And Takeout Pick
Shorty’s turns out big, foldable slices and whole pies that feel made for game nights and low-key evenings in.
Out on West Central, Shorty’s channels a classic New York slice joint with thin, chewy crusts and plenty of cheese. You can grab a couple of slices at the counter or call ahead for a whole pie when you don’t feel like cooking. It’s the kind of place locals rely on for predictable, satisfying pizza that travels well and feeds a crowd without fuss.
03
Best classic carryout
Delco Pizza
South Sandusky Street Corridor • Neighborhood Carryout Pizzeria • Family-Night Standby
Delco serves up hearty, toppings-heavy pies that feel tailor-made for family pizza night.
Delco is the sort of no-nonsense shop where the focus stays firmly on hot, generous pizzas, subs, and wings. Expect a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings done the way you remember from childhood takeout. With friendly staff and quick turnaround, it’s a go-to for busy weeknights or weekends when you want something reliable without the sit-down scene.
04
Best for variety
Loiee G’s Pizza
East Side Near Residential Neighborhoods • Hand-Tossed Pizza And Comfort-Food Spot • Great For Groups
Loiee G’s mixes hand-tossed pies with subs, pastas, and salads, making it easy to keep a whole group happy.
Known for generous portions and friendly service, Loiee G’s specializes in hand-tossed pizza available by the slice or as full pies. The menu stretches beyond pizza to include hearty pastas, subs, and soups, which is handy when not everyone at the table wants the same thing. It’s a comfortable choice for families, teams after a game, or anyone who likes leftovers for the next day.
05
Best chain option
Romeo’s Pizza
Columbus Pike Corridor • Regional Chain With Thick-Cut Pies • Late-Night And Delivery Pick
Romeo’s offers thick, flavorsome pies with reliable delivery for when you want pizza to come to you.
Located along Columbus Pike, Romeo’s brings a regional chain’s consistency to the local mix, with a menu built around substantial, sauce-forward pizzas. The crust tends to be on the thicker side, with bold specialty combinations and plenty of extras like wings and cheesy bread. With broad delivery coverage and convenient hours, it’s a solid backup when dining rooms are full or you’re settling in for a movie night at home.