01
Best overall pick
Crossroads Pizza
Carrollton Village Center • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A busy Carrollton staple turning out hearty, generously topped pies that feel made for small‑town Friday nights.
Crossroads Pizza is the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and the order board is always full of carryout tickets. The crust is sturdy enough to handle everything from classic pepperoni to fully loaded meat combos, and the cheese pull is the real deal. It’s an easy choice when you’re in Dellroy and want a reliably good, no‑nonsense pizza without driving to the big city.
02
Best for big, cheesy pies
Gionino's Pizzeria
Carrollton East Side • Neighborhood Pizza And Chicken Joint • Go-To For Takeout
A Northeast Ohio favorite known for its cheesy pizzas, bold toppings, and fried chicken that locals often add to their pizza order.
Gionino’s brings its well‑known Northeast Ohio style to Carrollton with thick blankets of cheese and a slightly chewy crust that travels well back to Dellroy. The menu leans toward crowd‑pleasers: classic pepperoni, hearty deluxe pies, and specialty combinations that feed a whole crew. It’s especially handy when you want to round out the order with wings or fried chicken for a cabin or campsite group at Atwood Lake.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Carrollton Shopping Strip • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Family-Friendly Choice
A familiar sit‑down spot where families can share pan pizzas, breadsticks, and a low‑stress weeknight meal.
The Carrollton Pizza Hut is a comfortable choice when you’re with kids or want a predictable sit‑down experience after a day at Atwood Lake. Classic pan pizza, breadsticks, and simple pasta dishes keep everyone at the table happy. For Dellroy locals, it’s also a convenient option when you want an easy online order and straightforward carryout on the way home.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Carrollton Main Corridor • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Delivery
Fast, customizable pizzas with reliable delivery that’s especially handy for cabins, rentals, and late arrivals around Atwood Lake.
Domino’s in the Carrollton area leans into speed and consistency, making it a smart pick when you’re more focused on timing than atmosphere. With online ordering and tracking, it’s easy to get a couple of large, topping‑heavy pies and an order of cheesy bread out to a rental near Dellroy or the lake. It’s also one of the more dependable options if you’re rolling into the area later in the evening and still want hot pizza.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek Village Center • Farm-To-Table Style Pizzeria • Destination Pizza Spot
A polished, ingredient-focused pizzeria that’s become a regional draw and is well worth the short country drive from Dellroy.
Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek has built a reputation on quality ingredients, thoughtful toppings, and a crust that balances chew and crispness. Expect creative combinations alongside well‑executed classics, plus a more modern, airy dining room than you’ll find in most small‑town shops. If you’re staying near Dellroy for a long weekend, this is the one place on the list that feels like an outing in itself rather than just another takeout stop.