01
Best overall pick
Dennison Yard
Downtown Dennison • Sit-Down Pizzeria And Pub • Local Favorite
A rail-side landmark where locals gather for generous, oven-baked pizzas and relaxed pub atmosphere.
Set just off the tracks, Dennison Yard feels like the village’s living room, with a crowd that runs from families to after-work regulars. The pizza is classic Ohio comfort—sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and topping combos that lean familiar rather than fussy. Go for a specialty pie, split a basket of wings, and plan to stay a while; this is the spot when you want pizza to feel like a night out, not just takeout.
02
Old-school classic
Pangrazio's Pizza
Nearby Gnadenhutten • Family-Run Pizza And Pasta Shop • Best For Big Appetites
A longtime Tuscarawas County staple known for hefty pies, plenty of sauce, and family-style dinners.
A short drive from Dennison, Pangrazio’s has the slightly time-warp feel of the old neighborhood pizza place everyone grew up with. The crust sits in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with a tangy red sauce and toppings layered right to the edge. It’s the kind of spot where ordering a large pizza and a tray of pasta feeds a whole crew without anyone leaving hungry.
03
Neighborhood chain favorite
Gionino's Pizzeria
Uhrichsville – Mccauley Drive Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Game Night
A go-to for thickly topped pies and fried chicken when you’re feeding a crowd at home.
Gionino’s is a familiar name across Northeast Ohio, and the Uhrichsville location is the one Dennison families call before kickoff. The crust is on the thicker side, with a generous hand on cheese and toppings, so even a couple of pizzas stretch further than you expect. Pair a sheet pizza with their chicken and JoJo potatoes and you’ve basically covered dinner for the whole living room.
04
Best for customizable pies
East of Chicago Pizza
Uhrichsville – North Side • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Picky Eaters
Build-your-own pies, multiple crust options, and crowd-pleasing combos make this an easy group choice.
East of Chicago leans into variety, with crusts that run from thin and crispy to their signature pan style, plus a long list of sauces and toppings. It’s especially handy when you’re trying to please kids, teens, and adults with very different ideas of the ‘right’ pizza. Order a few different styles, add some breadsticks, and let everyone claim their own corner slices.
05
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Uhrichsville – West Third Street Area • National Delivery Pizzeria • Late-Night Pick
Fast, consistent delivery pizza that Dennison locals fall back on when other kitchens have closed.
Domino’s might not be fancy, but it’s the place people call when the craving hits after a late shift or Friday night game. Between the customizable crusts, deal-heavy combos, and app tracking, it’s built for convenience as much as taste. Stick to your favorite topping lineup, add an order of cheesy bread, and you’ve got an easy, no-surprises option when you don’t feel like cooking or leaving the house.