01
Best overall pick
Tammy's Pizza
Grove City • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to Grove City staple serving loaded Columbus-style pies with a friendly, small-town feel.
Tammy's Pizza is the sort of place Derby locals happily drive to when they want a sure thing for dinner. The crust is thin but sturdy, toppings are generous, and the menu runs from classic pepperoni to hearty specialty pies that can feed a crowd. It is relaxed, kid-friendly, and consistent, which makes it an easy choice for both weeknights and game days.
02
Old-school classic
Zamarelli's Pizza Palace
Grove City • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Longtime Institution
A family-run spot known for cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a loyal following.
Zamarelli's has been a Grove City fixture for decades, and its fans are serious about their pizza. Expect square-cut pies with a crisp, thin crust and toppings that go right to the edge in true Columbus style. It is a straightforward, no-frills operation where the focus is on familiar flavors done the way locals have loved for years.
03
Best tavern-style stop
Plank's on Broadway
Historic Downtown Grove City • Lively Tavern With Standout Pizza • Best For Pizza And A Pint
A historic Grove City bar-restaurant turning out hearty, cheesy pies alongside cold beer and casual conversation.
Plank's on Broadway pairs character-filled old-building vibes with pizza that eats like a meal. The crust has a satisfying chew, the cheese is generous, and the toppings lean classic, making it ideal for sharing at the table. It is a comfortable choice when you want a place where adults can linger over a drink while still getting crowd-pleasing pizza.
04
Most reliable chain option
Donatos Pizza (Grove City)
Grove City Commercial Strip • Fast-Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Quick, Consistent Pies
A convenient pick for thin, edge-to-edge pepperoni and quick carryout on the way back to Derby.
The Grove City Donatos serves the brand’s signature thin crust with famously dense pepperoni coverage, making it a dependable option when you want something familiar. Ordering is easy, wait times are short, and the pizzas travel well for the drive back toward Derby. It is especially handy for busy nights when convenience matters as much as flavor.
05
Worth-the-drive option
Cristy's Pizza
Circleville • Family-Friendly Pizza Shop • Best For Families And Big Orders
A Circleville favorite offering crowd-pleasing pies, big salads, and plenty of space for groups.
Cristy's Pizza in Circleville is a natural choice when Derby residents are headed south and want to turn it into a pizza stop. The menu covers everything from classic cheese to loaded specialty pizzas, with crust and sauce that appeal to both kids and adults. It is also well set up for larger orders and party trays, making it useful for gatherings, teams, and family get-togethers.