01
Small-town staple
Mama Roses
Downtown Deshler • Family Diner And Pizza Shop • Local Favorite For Comfort Food
A homey Deshler go-to where you can grab a satisfying pizza alongside classic small-town diner fare.
Set right in the heart of Deshler, Mama Roses is the kind of place where locals linger over pizza and conversation. Pies lean toward classic Midwest comfort—generous cheese, familiar toppings, and a crust that holds up to it all. It is an easy choice when you want something casual, friendly, and close to home.
02
College-town legend
Campus Pollyeyes
Near Bgsu Campus In Bowling Green • Bustling College-Town Pizzeria • Stuffed-Breadstick Must-Try
A Bowling Green institution known for hearty pizzas and the stuffed breadsticks students rave about.
About a half-hour from Deshler, Campus Pollyeyes is a destination in its own right for anyone who loves over-the-top, cheesy pizza. The menu leans indulgent, with thick, loaded pies and their signature stuffed breadsticks that eat like a full meal. Expect a lively, student-heavy crowd and portions that make the drive worthwhile.
03
Classic pie night pick
Pisanello's Pizza
Downtown Bowling Green • Classic Ohio Pizza Parlor • Great For Families And Groups
A long-running downtown spot serving dependable, shareable pizzas in a relaxed, old-school setting.
Pisanello's in Bowling Green has the feel of a classic Main Street pizza parlor, with big tables, casual service, and pies built for sharing. Crusts are on the slightly thicker side, with plenty of cheese and a good mix of specialty and build-your-own options. It is a comfortable choice when you are bringing a crowd from Deshler or meeting friends halfway.
04
Best for game day
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
South Main Street, Findlay • Lively Sports Bar And Pizza Grill • Big-Menu, Big-Crowd Choice
A spacious Findlay spot pairing thick, topping-heavy pizzas with a full grill menu and plenty of TVs.
Beer Barrel in Findlay is a solid pick when you want pizza plus everything else—wings, burgers, and a long list of appetizers. Their pizzas run large and generous, with lots of cheese and toppings that make them ideal for sharing during a game. It is a good fit for mixed groups where not everyone is set on pizza but you definitely are.
05
Carryout hero
Heavenly Pizza
East Side Findlay • Takeout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Go-To For Easy Weeknight Pizza
A reliable Findlay favorite for made-to-order pizzas that travel well back to Deshler.
Heavenly Pizza focuses on straightforward, well-executed pies that hold up on the ride home, with crust options and toppings that cover all the basics. The operation is geared toward carryout and delivery, making it handy when you are passing through Findlay and want to bring dinner back toward Deshler. Call ahead on busy evenings and you can time your pickup right off the highway.