01
Classic downtown slice
The Original Pizza Place
Downtown Marietta • Old-School Pizza Parlor • Local Legend
A downtown Marietta staple serving crisp, square-cut pies and slices just a short walk from the riverfront.
This is the spot many Washington County locals think of first when someone mentions grabbing pizza in town. The crust runs on the thinner, crisp side with plenty of cheese and toppings, and you can order whole pies or mix and match slices if your group cannot agree. It is an easy stop to pair with a stroll along Front Street or a night out on the riverfront.
02
Best for delivery
Domino's Pizza – Pike Street
Pike Street Corridor, Marietta • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Fast, Reliable Option
Go-to delivery choice for Dexter City and rural addresses south of Caldwell when speed and consistency matter most.
If you are staying at a hotel along I-77 or renting a cabin in the countryside, this Domino’s on Pike Street is often the easiest way to feed a crowd. The menu hits all the familiar notes—hand-tossed, pan, and thin-crust pies plus wings, breads, and desserts—so everyone can find something. Order ahead online, then either swing through for carryout on your way back to Dexter City or have it meet you at the door.
03
Best for family night
Pizza Hut – Caldwell
Just Off I-77 In Caldwell • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Sit-Down Classic
A convenient stop near the interstate with roomy booths, pan pizzas, and plenty of kid-friendly choices.
For families coming in from ballgames, school events, or a run to town from Dexter City, the Caldwell Pizza Hut is an easy all-ages option. Classic pan and hand-tossed pizzas share the menu with pastas, wings, and a solid salad, and the roomy booths work well for teams or larger groups. Its location near the interstate also makes it a handy stop if you are heading north or south on I-77.
04
Small-town carryout favorite
Plus One Pizza – Caldwell
Caldwell Town Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Hearty, topping-loaded pies from a regional Ohio chain that feels tailored to small-town tastes.
Plus One leans into generous toppings and soft, chewy crusts that hold up well on the drive back to Dexter City. It is a popular choice for Friday-night carryout, whether you are feeding family or grabbing a couple of specialty pies for friends. Call ahead during peak hours—especially on game nights—so your order is ready when you roll through Caldwell.
05
Group-friendly pick
Pizza Hut – Marietta
East Marietta Shopping Strip • Sit-Down And Carryout Chain • Best For Larger Groups
A busy location near big-box stores that works well for fueling up after errands or a river day.
If your plans take you to Marietta for shopping or a day on the water, this Pizza Hut is an easy place to regroup over pizza, wings, and pitchers of soda. The dining room can handle bigger parties, and the menu has enough variety to keep kids and picky eaters happy. It is also a practical carryout stop if you want to head straight back to Dexter City with dinner in the car.