01
Closest classic slice
DiCarlo's Pizza Rayland
Rayland & Route 7 • Classic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Closest Go-To For Dillonvale
A quick hop down Route 7 brings you to square-cut DiCarlo's pies with that signature cheese-on-after baking style.
This Rayland outpost is the easiest way for Dillonvale locals to get the region’s most famous style of pizza without heading to the bigger river towns. The menu is simple and built around those light, crispy squares, so it is ideal for a fast pickup order. Call ahead on busy evenings, grab a box, and you will be back in the village before the pizza has time to cool.
02
Best for sharing with a crowd
DeFelice Brothers Pizza Tiltonsville
Tiltonsville Riverfront • Neighborhood Pizza And Subs Joint • Best For Big Groups
Thicker, cheese-heavy pies and loaded subs make this Tiltonsville spot a solid choice when you are feeding a whole crew.
DeFelice in Tiltonsville leans into hearty, saucy pizzas that hold up well on the short drive back to Dillonvale. Specialty pies, wings, and subs mean everyone can find something they like, from pepperoni purists to fans of meat-heavy combos. It is a dependable pick for Friday nights, birthday parties, or game-day spreads.
03
Iconic regional stop
DiCarlo's Pizza Steubenville
Downtown Steubenville • Old-School Regional Favorite • Iconic Ohio Valley Style
The Steubenville original for square-cut, cheese-topped-after-the-oven slices that locals happily drive for.
If you want the full DiCarlo's experience, the Steubenville shop is worth the extra drive from Dillonvale. Expect a straightforward menu, hot trays of sauce-slathered crust, and a flurry of cold cheese going on just before your box is closed. Go earlier in the evening if you prefer a shorter wait, and order extra because these light, crisp squares disappear fast.
04
Most versatile menu
DeFelice Brothers Pizza Shadyside
Shadyside Main Strip • Family Pizzeria With Italian Favorites • Best For Variety
Across the river in Shadyside, this DeFelice location pairs Ohio Valley-style pies with pasta, salads, and wings.
Shadyside’s DeFelice is a handy option when your group wants more than just pizza. The crust runs a touch thicker, with generous cheese and toppings, and you can round out the meal with baked pasta, sandwiches, and fried appetizers. It is a comfortable, family-friendly choice if you do not mind a short scenic drive along the river from Dillonvale.
05
Best delivery-friendly choice
Vocelli Pizza St. Clairsville
St. Clairsville Retail Corridor • Chain Carryout And Delivery Shop • Delivery-Friendly Option
A reliable pick near the St. Clairsville shopping strip, offering customizable pies and late-hour carryout or delivery.
When you are out by the stores in St. Clairsville or need something that travels well, Vocelli is a practical option. The crust is classic American style, with a wide range of toppings, sauces, and sides so you can build everything from simple one-topping pies to loaded works pizzas. It is especially handy for larger orders when you want predictable timing and easy parking.