01
Best overall pick
Il Gusto Pizza & Pasta
Kenwood / Dillonvale • Ny-Style Pizzeria And Italian Kitchen • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
Hand-tossed New York–style pies, friendly service, and a cozy dining room make Il Gusto an easy go-to near Dillonvale.
Il Gusto feels like the neighborhood spot every suburb wishes it had, with big foldable slices and crisp crusts that hold up under generous toppings. The menu leans Italian-American, so you can pair your pie with solid pastas, garlic knots, and a glass of wine without it feeling fussy. It’s the kind of place where staff remember regulars and takeout boxes are practically a weeknight staple.
02
Best for creative toppings
Dewey's Pizza (Kenwood)
Kenwood Towne Centre • Bustling Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For Families And Groups
Dewey’s pairs a chewy, flavorful crust with inventive topping combos in a bright, loud dining room that works well for kids and big parties.
Here, pizza is a bit of a show: you can watch the crew toss dough and build pies in the open kitchen while you wait. Signature creations like the Edgar Allan Poe or the Green Lantern lean into bold flavors without getting gimmicky, and half-and-half pies make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. Expect a short wait at peak times, but fast-moving service and consistently good salads help it feel worth it.
03
Classic comfort pick
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Montgomery Road Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza And Pasta Joint • Comfort-Food Standby
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta serves straightforward, satisfying pies and red-sauce favorites just up the road from Dillonvale.
This spot leans into the idea of classic East Coast comfort: sturdy crust, well-seasoned sauce, and plenty of cheese. Beyond pizza, the baked pastas, subs, and garlic bread make it easy to feed a hungry crew without overthinking the order. It’s a reliable option when you want something familiar, filling, and close by after a game or a late shift.
04
Best for Detroit-style
Taglio Bar + Pizzeria (Montgomery)
Montgomery • Detroit-Style And Bar Pie Spot • Best For Craft Pizza Night
Taglio is all about thick, airy squares with caramelized cheese edges, punchy toppings, and a solid drink list.
If you like a pizza with some heft, Taglio’s Detroit-style pans deliver: light inside, crisp on the bottom, and ringed with a cheesy crust that borders on addictive. Toppings skew modern—think hot honey, spicy pepperoni cups, and fresh herbs—so it’s a fun place to linger over a pie and a beer rather than rush in and out. It makes a great option when you want something a little more destination-worthy without driving all the way downtown.
05
Best for grab-and-go slices
Ramundo's Pizzeria (Mt. Lookout)
Mt. Lookout / East Side • Casual Slice Shop • Late-Night Slice Stop
Ramundo’s is the move when you’re craving a giant New York–style slice and don’t mind a short drive toward the East Side.
Known for oversized slices you can fold in half, Ramundo’s keeps things low-key and focused on the basics: good dough, balanced sauce, and plenty of topping options by the slice or whole pie. It’s especially handy when you’re already heading toward Mt. Lookout for drinks or a concert and want something fast that doesn’t taste like chain pizza. For many Cincinnatians, it’s the place they introduce out-of-town friends to when they say, “show me your favorite slice.”