01
Best overall pick
571 Grill & Draft House
New Carlisle – Oh-571 Corridor • Craft Beer Grill With Creative Pizzas • Best For Pizza And A Pint
A lively small-town grill where you can pair a well-crafted pizza with one of the best tap lists around.
Known first for its burgers and beer, 571 Grill also turns out impressive pizzas with nicely blistered crusts and generous toppings. It is the spot locals suggest when you want a relaxed night out rather than a quick slice. Go for a signature specialty pie, then linger over a pint and the friendly small-town atmosphere.
02
Cozy neighborhood choice
Carmela's Pizzeria
New Carlisle – Near Downtown • Classic Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A straightforward, no-fuss pizzeria with dependable pies and a family-friendly feel.
Carmela's leans into the familiar comforts of classic Midwest pizza: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and sauce with just enough tang. It is an easy pick for carryout on a busy weeknight or a casual family dinner. Expect friendly service, generous portions, and solid value for the money.
03
Springfield staple
Catanzaro's Pizza & Subs
Springfield – East Of Donnelsville • Old-School Pizza And Sub Shop • Local Favorite
A long-running Springfield shop that delivers hearty, toppings-heavy pies and classic subs out toward Donnelsville.
Catanzaro's is the kind of old-school place people grow up with and never quite give up. The pizzas lean generous, with plenty of cheese and toppings and a crust built to hold it all. Add in their hearty subs and reliable delivery coverage toward Donnelsville, and it becomes a go-to for group orders and game days.
04
Custom-topping workhorse
Domino's Pizza
New Carlisle – South Main Street • National Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Most Customizable
A familiar option when you want to build-your-own pizza, track it on the app, and have it show up hot at the door.
This New Carlisle Domino's is all about speed, consistency, and choice. The online ordering and tracking make it especially handy for Donnelsville households juggling busy schedules. With customizable crusts, sauces, and toppings, it suits picky eaters and large groups who all want something a little different.
05
Value-focused delivery
Papa Johns Pizza
New Carlisle – North Main Street • Takeout And Delivery Pizza Chain • Best For Late-Night Orders
A go-to chain choice with a sweeter sauce, thick cheese coverage, and late hours that can save a late-night craving.
Papa Johns in New Carlisle appeals to those who like a slightly sweeter red sauce and lots of cheese, plus the familiar garlic sauce on the side. Frequent deals and bundles make it a budget-friendly way to feed a crowd within a short drive of Donnelsville. It is especially useful when you need a reliable, open-late option after ballgames or long shifts.