01
Best overall pick
Dola Jean's
Downtown Dover • Modern Detroit-Style Pizzeria And Cocktail Bar • Best For A Night Out
Detroit-style pans, crisp pepperoni cups, and a polished bar make Dola Jean’s the place when you want pizza to feel like an occasion.
This downtown spot leans into thick, airy Detroit-style squares with caramelized edges and bold topping combos, plus a few thoughtful salads and small plates. The space feels more like a modern neighborhood restaurant than a classic pizza joint, with a solid cocktail list and a pace that suits lingering over a second round. It’s the go-to when you want to impress out-of-town guests without leaving Dover.
02
Classic local institution
Penso's Pizza
North Dover • Old-School Square-Cut Ohio Pizzeria • Classic Hometown Institution
Penso’s has been serving no-nonsense, square-cut pies for generations and still feels like the pizza many Dover locals grew up with.
Penso’s is all about familiar flavors done right: a sturdy, well-browned crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings piled edge to edge, cut into easy-to-share squares. There’s a strong nostalgia factor here, and it shows in the steady stream of regulars picking up Friday-night orders. If you want a pie that tastes like Tuscarawas County tradition, this is your stop.
03
Most ingredient-focused pies
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek, Southwest Of Dover • Farm-To-Table Takeout And Delivery Shop • Best For Creative Toppings
Park Street Pizza brings a farm-forward mindset to pizza, topping well-fermented dough with local meats, veggies, and seasonal specials.
A short drive to Sugarcreek gets you to one of the area’s most talked-about pizza counters, known for careful sourcing and a menu that changes with the seasons. Expect topping combinations you won’t see at a typical corner shop, plus standout wings and sides that make a full meal out of takeout night. Order ahead on busy weekends—locals know this place fills the queue early.
04
Best chain-style option
Gionino's Pizzeria
New Philadelphia, Just North Of Dover • Casual Regional Chain Carryout • Reliable Game-Day Choice
Gionino’s delivers classic thick-crust pies, generous toppings, and fried chicken in portions that are ideal for feeding a crowd.
This regional chain location just up the road is a go-to when you need something everyone will say yes to, from loaded specialty pizzas to big boxes of jojo potatoes. The crust runs on the thicker side with plenty of cheese, and the menu is broad enough to cover picky eaters and big groups. It’s hard to beat for last-minute game-day spreads or easy family dinners.
05
Best small-town side trip
Pangrazio's Pizza
Dennison, East Of Dover • Family-Run Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Worth-The-Drive Hidden Gem
Pangrazio’s feels like a classic small-town pizza parlor, serving hearty pies and subs that make a detour to Dennison feel justified.
Set in nearby Dennison, Pangrazio’s has the relaxed, everyone-knows-everyone vibe that defines a good small-town pizzeria. The crust lands between thin and thick, sturdy enough for plenty of toppings without getting soggy, and the menu branches into subs and pastas that travel well. It’s a smart pick if you’re exploring the eastern side of the county and want a sit-down slice with a local feel.