01
Best overall pick
Creno's Pizza Dresden
Main Street In Dresden • Carryout-Focused Hometown Pizzeria • Classic Small-Town Staple
Dependable, cheesy pies with crust options and plenty of toppings make Creno’s a go-to for quick takeout in the village.
Situated right on Main Street, Creno’s is the spot many locals think of first when someone says “pizza night.” The menu leans into classic Ohio-style pies with a choice of crusts, generous cheese, and familiar topping combos. Call ahead on busy evenings, because this place earns a steady stream of regulars grabbing boxes to go.
02
Family dinner standby
Main Street Pizzeria, LLC
North End Of Main Street • Casual Dine-In And Takeout Spot • Best For Big Groups
A relaxed small-town pizzeria with roomy tables, shareable pies, and friendly service that works well for families or ball teams.
Main Street Pizzeria is the kind of place where the staff remembers repeat customers and kids can split a large pie without anyone going hungry. The pizza leans hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus subs and wings if not everyone at the table wants the same thing. It’s a handy choice when you need to feed a crowd after a game or school event in Dresden.
03
Destination pie in Zanesville
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Old-School Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Worth The Drive For A Sit-Down Meal
A long-running Zanesville favorite, known for its saucy pies, red-sauce comfort food, and bustling dining room.
If you’re willing to make the short drive from Dresden, Adornetto’s delivers a classic Italian-American experience that feels like a night out. Pizzas come with a sweet-leaning sauce, ample cheese, and a crust that holds up under generous toppings. With pastas, salads, and carafes of soft drinks on the table, it’s a natural choice for birthdays, date nights, or treating visiting family.
04
Crispy thin-crust favorite
Donatos Pizza – Zanesville North
North Zanesville Near The Shopping Area • Thin-Crust Ohio Chain Pizzeria • Game-Day And Party Favorite
Known for its edge-to-edge toppings and crispy thin crust, Donatos is a convenient option when you need predictable, crowd-pleasing pizza fast.
This Donatos location is easy to hit when you’re already in Zanesville running errands or shopping. The hallmark is that square-cut, thin-crust pizza loaded all the way to the edge, which makes it ideal for sharing with a group. Order ahead for pickup before a big game or grab delivery back toward Dresden when you don’t feel like cooking.
05
Crowd-pleasing variety
Pizza Cottage – Zanesville
South Zanesville Corridor • Casual Regional Pizza Restaurant • Best For Varied Toppings And Salads
A roomy, laid-back spot with customizable pies, specialty combinations, and enough non-pizza options to keep everyone at the table happy.
Pizza Cottage offers a broad menu, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pizzas piled high with meats and veggies. The dining room has a relaxed, family-friendly feel, and the salad bar and appetizers make it easy to turn a simple pizza run into a full meal. It’s a smart pick when your group wants pizza but also appreciates options like salads, subs, or wings on the side.