01
Best overall pick
Black Dog Pizzeria
Karric Square / Northwest Dublin • New York-Style Slice Shop • Local Favorite For Serious Pizza Fans
A cozy, detail-obsessed shop turning out chewy, foldable pies and standout garlic knots.
Tucked just off Karric Square Drive, Black Dog feels like the kind of neighborhood spot regulars are reluctant to talk about because they want to keep it to themselves. The menu leans into classic New York-style pies with a slow-fermented crust that has real chew and flavor. Order a specialty pizza and a side of their award-winning garlic knots if you want to understand why locals will happily drive across town for it.
02
Family favorite
Dewey's Pizza
Bridge Park District • Craft Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families And Groups
Lively Bridge Park spot with creative topping combos, open kitchen energy, and plenty of room for groups.
Set in the heart of Bridge Park, Dewey's is a go-to when you need pizza that can please a crowd without feeling generic. The menu mixes playful specialty pies with build-your-own options, and you can watch the crew toss dough and work the ovens while you wait. It’s an easy choice before a stroll over the Dublin Link pedestrian bridge or a night out at the nearby bars.
03
Old-school classic
Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant
Frantz Road Corridor • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Cozy Dine-In And Carryout Staple
A long-running, no-frills favorite known for hearty pies, red-sauce comfort, and friendly service.
Enrico's on Frantz Road feels like it could have been your family's regular spot for decades, even if you're just walking in for the first time. The crust hits that middle ground between thin and doughy, sturdy enough to handle generous toppings and plenty of cheese. It's as reliable for a quick carryout night as it is for a casual sit-down meal with a big salad and a classic pasta on the side.
04
Columbus-style staple
Tommy's Pizza
Sawmill Corridor • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Classic Columbus-Style Pies
Crispy, square-cut thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings at a laid-back north Dublin outpost.
If you're curious about true Columbus-style pizza, Tommy's on the Sawmill side of Dublin is the reference point. The crust is ultra-thin and crisp, with toppings spread right out to the edge and cut into party squares that disappear faster than you expect. Pair a pepperoni and sausage pie with a cold drink, and you’ll understand why so many locals grew up on this exact style of pizza.
05
Game-day spot
Gallo's Pizzeria
Perimeter Loop / Near Dublin Methodist • Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Best For Pizza And A Game
A lively pizzeria-bar hybrid serving hefty pies, wings, and plenty of screens for sports.
Just off the Perimeter Loop near Dublin Methodist Hospital, Gallo's is where you go when you want pizza with a side of game-day energy. The pies skew hearty, with chewy crusts, big toppings, and styles that pair naturally with wings and a draft beer. It’s an easy choice for watching the Buckeyes or grabbing a relaxed meal after youth sports and weekend errands.