01
Best overall pick
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Destination For Food Lovers
A short drive from Dundee, Park Street Pizza is the standout for creative, farm-fresh pies and a lively small-town vibe.
Park Street Pizza feels like the kind of place people plan their weekend around, with toppings that lean heavily on local meats and seasonal produce. The crust strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp, and the menu always has a few fun specialty combinations alongside the classics. Go a little early on busy nights if you want a relaxed sit-down experience rather than just grabbing takeout.
02
Small-town favorite
East of Chicago Pizza
Baltic • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Easy Takeout
This Baltic outpost of East of Chicago is a convenient, dependable stop for thick, satisfying pies on the way back to Dundee.
If you’re coming up from the south, East of Chicago in Baltic is a natural grab-and-go option that still feels local. Their pan and deep-dish styles are hearty enough to feed a crew, and the toppings are generous rather than fussy. It’s a solid choice when you want familiar flavors, quick service, and plenty of leftovers.
03
Fast, customizable pick
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
When it’s late or the weather’s bad, Domino’s in New Philadelphia is the go-to for quick, customizable pizza brought out toward Dundee.
Domino’s shines on convenience, with an app-based ordering system that lets you tweak sauces, crusts, and toppings down to the last detail. The New Philadelphia location moves orders quickly and tends to get the bake and cut right, even on busy game nights. It’s not a sit-down destination, but it’s exactly what you want when the priority is hot pizza at your door with minimal hassle.
04
Classic family option
Pizza Hut
Dover • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Best For Family Dine-In
The Dover Pizza Hut offers familiar pan pizzas and roomy booths that work well for family dinners after a day exploring the area.
If you grew up with red-checkered tablecloths and pan pizza, the Dover Pizza Hut hits the nostalgia button in all the right ways. It’s one of the easier places nearby to handle a mixed group, from kids who want personal pan pies to adults aiming for wings and a salad bar. Service is straightforward, and the predictable menu makes ordering for a crowd painless.
05
Budget-friendly stop
Little Caesars Pizza
New Philadelphia • Take-And-Go Pizza Chain • Best For Quick Grab-And-Go
Little Caesars in New Philadelphia is ideal when you need a hot-and-ready pizza fast without stretching the budget.
This spot is all about speed and value, making it a practical choice on the way through town with hungry kids in the backseat. The Hot-N-Ready pies are usually in the warmer and out the door in minutes, and the Detroit-style or stuffed crust options add a bit more interest if you have time to place a custom order. It’s not fancy, but it reliably fills the gap between errands, practices, and the drive back to Dundee.