01
Best overall pick
Michael Angelo's Pizza & Subs
In Kenton • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to Kenton standby known for generous toppings, hearty crust, and dependable carryout.
For many Hardin County residents, Michael Angelo's is the default answer when someone suggests pizza night. The pies lean hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the subs are a solid backup if not everyone is in a pizza mood. It is an easy, no-fuss stop when you are coming into Kenton from Dunkirk for errands or a ballgame.
02
Top college-town slice
Padrone's Pizza
Near Ohio Northern University In Ada • College-Town Pizza Joint • Great For Late Dinners
A lively Ada staple turning out big, cheesy pies that fuel students and locals alike.
Padrone's sits right in Ada's college orbit, which means it understands late cravings and big-group orders. Expect classic Midwestern-style pies with a soft, chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and crowd-pleasing toppings. It is a smart pick when you are meeting friends halfway between Dunkirk and Ada or grabbing takeout after a game on campus.
03
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
Ada Main Corridor • Buffet-Style Pizzeria • Best For Families And Groups
A flexible option with pan, thin, and specialty pizzas plus a salad bar that keeps everyone at the table happy.
If your crew can never agree on one style of pizza, East of Chicago in Ada makes life easier. The menu runs from thick, saucy pan pies to thinner crusts and specialty creations, and the buffet format on certain days is especially handy with kids. It is the sort of place where you can linger, refill plates, and still head back to Dunkirk without a long drive home.
04
Best for takeout night
AJ's Heavenly Pizza
Downtown Bluffton • Family-Friendly Pizza And Subs Shop • Carryout Standout
Bluffton’s favorite for well-built pies, wings, and subs that travel well back to Dunkirk.
AJ's Heavenly Pizza has that classic small-town feel: friendly service, familiar faces, and a menu built around reliable pizza and subs. The crust has enough structure to stay good on the drive back, and the wings and sides round out a full family meal. Pair a specialty pie with breadsticks and you have an easy Friday-night spread without cooking.
05
Best dine-in experience
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
South Side Of Findlay • Sports-Bar Pizza Grill • Best For Game-Day Outings
A roomy grill with big-screen TVs, loaded specialty pizzas, and a full menu for non-pizza eaters.
When you want more of an outing than a quick pickup, Beer Barrel in Findlay is worth the extra drive from Dunkirk. The thick-cut pepperoni, piled-high toppings, and shareable appetizers make it ideal for watching a game or celebrating a win. With burgers, salads, and a full bar, it works just as well for mixed groups where not everyone is craving a slice.