01
Closest slice to home
Patton Grocery & Pizza
In The Heart Of East Fultonham • Small-Town Carryout And Convenience Stop • Closest Option For East Fultonham Locals
A no-fuss spot where you can grab a hot, satisfying pizza without leaving East Fultonham.
Patton Grocery & Pizza is the classic small-town combo of corner store and pizza counter, making it an easy choice when you just want something hot and filling. Expect straightforward pies with familiar toppings, friendly service, and quick turnaround for pickup orders. It is especially handy on weeknights when you would rather skip the drive into Zanesville.
02
Classic Zanesville institution
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Maple Avenue, North Zanesville • Old-School Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Beloved Local Institution
A long-running Zanesville favorite known for its saucy, cheesy pies and sit-down Italian comfort.
Adornetto's is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to get pizza in Zanesville, and it is worth the drive from East Fultonham. The pizzas come with a slightly sweet, generously applied sauce, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings that feel nostalgic in the best way. With roomy booths and a full Italian menu, it works just as well for a family outing as it does for a relaxed date night.
03
Best for big groups
Pizza Cottage
Maple Avenue Commercial Strip • Family-Friendly Pizza Chain Restaurant • Great For Families And Teams
Lively and spacious, this spot serves crowd-pleasing pies that are easy to share after games, practices, or errands in town.
Pizza Cottage leans into big, shareable pizzas with plenty of topping combinations, from loaded meat pies to veggie-heavy options. The dining room has the feel of a casual gathering place, with enough space for sports teams, birthday gatherings, and family dinners. It is a handy choice when you are already on Maple Avenue running errands and need to feed a group without overthinking it.
04
Drive-thru favorite
Maxwell's Pizza
Maysville Pike, South Of Zanesville • Drive-Thru And Takeout Pizzeria • Best Grab-And-Go Option
A convenient drive-thru pizzeria with hearty pies, subs, and wings ideal for quick takeout on the way home.
Maxwell's Pizza is built for speed without giving up that local-pizza-shop feel. The drive-thru setup makes it especially appealing for East Fultonham residents cutting through the south side of Zanesville after work or errands. Go for a classic pepperoni or one of their specialty pies and add a side of wings if you are feeding a hungry crowd at home.
05
Chain comfort pick
Donatos Pizza
Maple Avenue Corridor In Zanesville • Ohio-Based Thin-Crust Pizza Chain • Consistent Chain Favorite
Reliable, thin-crust pizza piled edge-to-edge with toppings, ideal when you want something familiar and fast.
Donatos offers a very different style from the heavier local pies, with square-cut, thin-crust pizzas that come loaded from edge to edge with toppings. The Maple Avenue location is easy to reach during a quick trip into Zanesville, and online ordering makes pickup or delivery straightforward. It is a solid choice when you want predictable, consistent pizza and maybe a salad or wings on the side.