01
Best overall pick
Ianazone's Pizza by Coulter's
North Market Street In East Palestine • Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria With Generous Toppings • Go-To For Loaded Pies And Wings
A local standby turning out hearty, topping-packed pizzas that feel built for game night and family gatherings.
Ianazone's Pizza by Coulter's is the kind of small-town shop where a single pie can feed a crowd and still leave you with leftovers. The crust is sturdy enough to hold serious amounts of cheese, pepperoni, and whatever else you pile on, making it a natural fit for shareable orders. Call ahead on busy evenings, because regulars know this is one of the village’s most reliable pizza counters.
02
Family-run favorite
Cozza's Pizza
Walnut Street In East Palestine • Family-Owned Takeout Shop • Best For Comfort-Food Pizza Night
A long-running family operation known for straightforward, satisfying pies and a loyal hometown following.
Cozza's Pizza leans into the kind of comforting, no-fuss pizza that makes sense any night of the week. The menu sticks to the classics, but the sauce, cheese, and crust balance has that dialed-in feel that comes from doing the same thing well for years. Grab a couple of pizzas and a side or two and you’ve got an easy, hometown-style dinner that travels well back to the couch or campsite.
03
Classic regional chain
Pizza Joe's
East Taggart Street In East Palestine • Casual Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Party Trays And Value Deals
A regional favorite with plenty of sizes, specials, and sheet pizzas that make feeding a crowd straightforward.
Pizza Joe's is a smart pick when you are ordering for a team, classroom, or birthday crowd and need lots of slices fast. The menu covers everything from personal pies to big rectangular trays, with toppings and combos built for sharing. It’s also one of the better spots in town to watch for coupons and specials that stretch a group pizza budget a little further.
04
National name you know
Pizza Hut
North Market Street In East Palestine • Familiar Chain Carryout And Delivery • Best For Late-Night Cravings And Big-Brand Comfort
The East Palestine outpost of a national chain, serving the pan pizzas, breadsticks, and wings you already know by heart.
When you want something predictable and quick, the local Pizza Hut delivers exactly what you expect, from stuffed crust to thick-cut pan pies. It’s a reliable option for late-evening cravings or nights when you need easy online ordering and delivery. Pair a couple of pizzas with wings and breadsticks and you have a crowd-pleasing spread with zero guesswork.
05
Worth-the-drive option
Gionino's Pizzeria
Columbiana, A Short Drive Northwest • Popular Regional Pizzeria • Best For Variety Beyond Basic Cheese And Pepperoni
A nearby regional spot known for flavorful pies and a wider menu that rewards a quick drive out of the village.
If you are willing to hop in the car for a few extra minutes, Gionino's Pizzeria in Columbiana broadens your options with a solid lineup of specialty pizzas. The crust has enough character to stand up to bolder toppings, and the menu ranges far enough that everyone at the table can find something that fits their taste. It is a handy choice when you want to mix things up beyond your usual East Palestine rotation.