01
Classic Ohio Valley slice
DiCarlo's Pizza – Wintersville
Wintersville Town Center • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Best For Regional Style Purists
A Wintersville institution serving the signature Ohio Valley square-cut pizza that locals grow up on.
If you have never tried Ohio Valley-style pizza, this is the place to start: airy crust baked in the oven, then topped with sauce and a generous layer of cold cheese as it comes out of the pan. The squares are simple, salty, and addictive, especially hot from the box in your car. It is a no-frills counter-service experience, but the line of regulars tells you everything you need to know.
02
Neighborhood crowd-pleaser
Ray's Pizza
Wintersville Residential Strip • Casual Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Carryout
Generous toppings and friendly service make this a go-to spot when Wintersville families order in.
Ray's leans into classic, slightly thicker rounds piled high with cheese and pepperoni, plus a strong lineup of subs and wings. It is the kind of place where staff recognize repeat customers, orders come out hot and on time, and the price-to-portion ratio feels fair. For East Springfield residents, it is an easy swing into Wintersville for a reliable Friday night pizza run.
03
Old-school sit-down pick
Naples Spaghetti House
Steubenville Hilltop District • Old-School Italian Restaurant • Best For Lingering Dinners
A long-running Italian spot where pizza shares the spotlight with big plates of pasta and sauce.
Naples Spaghetti House is the classic red-sauce restaurant people recommend when you want more than just a quick slice. The pizzas lean traditional—chewy crust, well-seasoned sauce, and a modest char from the oven—served alongside heaping bowls of spaghetti and house specialties. It is a comfortable choice for a relaxed dinner after a day on the road or around town, with enough menu variety to keep everyone at the table happy.
04
Lively family spot
Scaffidi's Restaurant & Tavern
West Steubenville • Lively Italian Tavern • Best For Groups And Families
A modern Italian tavern atmosphere with pizzas, pastas, and appetizers made for sharing.
Scaffidi's pairs a busy, upbeat dining room with a menu that treats pizza as seriously as the rest of its Italian comfort food. The pies tend to be loaded—think plenty of cheese, hearty toppings, and crust with enough structure to hold it all together. It is a good pick when you have a group coming in from East Springfield and want a place where kids, grandparents, and everyone in between can settle in for a full meal.
05
Takeout staple
Giannamore's Pizza
North Steubenville • Takeout-Focused Pizza Shop • Best Value Pies
A long-running carryout stop known for straightforward, satisfying pizzas at wallet-friendly prices.
Giannamore's focuses on doing familiar pizza very well: crisp yet tender crust, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings that feel just right for game day or movie night. The menu stays tight and efficient, which helps keep wait times reasonable even on busy evenings. For East Springfield locals willing to make a short drive toward Steubenville, it is an easy add to the regular rotation when you want a stack of boxes without a big bill.