01
Classic local standby
TJ's Pizza
Rural Stretch Between Elida And Lima • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Decades of thin-crust, generously topped pies served from a no-frills, locals-first pizza shop.
TJ's is the kind of place people grow up on, with crisp-edged, square-cut pizzas and plenty of cheese. It is especially strong on classic combo pies and pepperoni, with a crust that stays sturdy under all the toppings. Call-ahead carryout is the move on busy weekends, when regulars line up for their usual orders.
02
Best in-village option
Poppy's Elida Depot
Village Center Near Elida • Family-Friendly Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families
A cozy hometown stop for pizza, subs, and casual dinners right in Elida.
Set in a laid-back, small-town space, Poppy's hits a sweet spot for families who want easygoing dine-in without heading into Lima. The pizzas lean hearty rather than fussy, with plenty of toppings and kid-friendly options alongside subs and other comfort staples. It is an easy choice when you want a relaxed meal close to home and something on the menu for everyone.
03
Pizza plus big grinders
Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders
Elida Road Corridor In Lima • Counter-Service Pizza And Grinders • Best For Quick Lunches
A versatile stop where you can pair a solid pie with hot oven-baked grinders and quick service.
Bellacino's sits along the busy Elida Road strip, making it a convenient choice when you are out running errands or meeting up for a casual bite. The menu goes well beyond pizza, with hefty grinders baked to order and plenty of mix-and-match topping combinations. It is especially good for lunch or early dinners when you need something filling, fast, and easy to split with a friend.
04
Best for game-day gatherings
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
West Lima Near Allentown Road • Lively Sports-Bar Style Pizza Grill • Best For Game Days
Big specialty pizzas, a full grill menu, and plenty of TVs make this a go-to for groups and sports nights.
Beer Barrel combines a broad pizza lineup with a full bar and grill atmosphere, so it works as well for watching the game as it does for a family dinner. The pizzas skew indulgent, with loaded toppings, shareable sizes, and crowd-pleasing flavor combos. If you are planning a night out with friends or need a spot that can handle a larger group, this is an easy recommendation.
05
Old-school carryout hero
Curly's Pizza & Subs
North Lima Neighborhood • Old-School Carryout Pizza And Sub Shop • Takeout Standby
A long-running neighborhood shop known for hearty, square-cut pizzas and straightforward subs.
Curly's has classic small-shop energy: limited seating, a well-worn counter, and a steady stream of regulars grabbing boxes to go. The crust is sturdy with a nice chew, and pies come generously sauced and cheesed, ideal for feeding a hungry crew. It is a smart pick when you want reliable takeout without overthinking your order.