01
Best overall pick
DeStazio's
Village Center Elmore • Family-Run Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Inventive specialty pies and friendly counter service make DeStazio's the go-to pizza stop right in Elmore.
DeStazio's feels like the classic small-town pizzeria, with locals popping in for carryout and families grabbing a few pies for game night. The menu leans into creative toppings alongside familiar favorites, so you can keep it simple or try something a bit different without leaving town. It is the spot most Elmore residents will recommend first when you ask where to get pizza.
02
Best bar pie
The Portage Inn
Portage River Corridor Elmore • Tavern With House-Made Pizza • Best For Late Nights
A welcoming tavern known for surprisingly good house-made pizzas that pair perfectly with a cold drink.
The Portage Inn is a staple roadside stop where the pizza holds its own against the lively bar atmosphere. Thin, shareable pies come out hot and crisp, ideal for splitting with friends over a round of drinks after a ball game or a long drive. It is a great option when you want a laid-back night out instead of a quick takeout run.
03
Best short-drive takeout
Mama Mary's Pizza
Downtown Woodville • Carryout Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
A dependable nearby shop turning out classic Northwest Ohio-style pies and hearty subs just a few minutes west of Elmore.
In nearby Woodville, Mama Mary's is a practical choice when you are already out on US-20 and want an easy pickup on the way home. The crust is sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, and the menu covers the essentials from pepperoni to deluxe combos and baked subs. It is the kind of place locals keep in their phone contacts for busy weeknights.
04
Best sit-down option
Genoa Pizza and Pasta
Historic Downtown Genoa • Casual Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Families
A relaxed small-town Italian spot where pizza shares the spotlight with pasta, salads, and kid-friendly favorites.
Genoa Pizza and Pasta, a short drive north of Elmore, is a good pick when some of the group wants pizza and others are craving pasta or a fuller meal. Pies come in familiar styles with plenty of topping choices, and the booths and tables make it easy to settle in with kids or a larger group. It works well for low-key birthday dinners, team outings, or Sunday family meals.
05
Classic regional choice
Depot Pizza
Downtown Fremont • Old-School Sports Bar Pizzeria • Best For Game Day
A long-running Fremont favorite serving crunchy, shareable pizzas in a lively, sports-friendly bar setting.
If you are willing to drive a bit farther, Depot Pizza in Fremont offers that classic, slightly nostalgic Ohio bar-pizza experience. The dining room leans casual and sports-focused, with pizzas built for sharing across a big table of friends and family. It is a natural choice when you want to catch a game, order a couple of large pies, and linger for a while.