01
Best overall pick
Cozzeria Pizzeria
Downtown Elyria • Deep-Dish And Pan-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Hearty Pies
Go to Cozzeria when you want a thick, cheesy pie that feels like a full meal.
Set along Cleveland Street, Cozzeria leans into generous deep-dish and pan pizzas with crisped edges and plenty of cheese. The menu keeps things straightforward—classic toppings, a few specialty combinations, and a focus on doing the basics really well. It’s the spot locals recommend when you ask where to get a reliably satisfying, shareable pizza in town.
02
Classic local slice
Angelina's Pizza
North Elyria • Old-School Carryout Shop • Best For A Classic Pepperoni Pie
Angelina’s is the no-nonsense neighborhood joint for a classic, foldable Ohio-style slice.
Angelina’s keeps things casual and familiar, with a menu centered on thin-to-medium crust pizzas that travel well for takeout or delivery. The pepperoni is the move here, with that curled, crispy edge locals look for on a Friday night pizza. It’s the kind of place that remembers your regular order and keeps the focus on quick, hot pies.
03
Italian-leaning option
Sambino's Pizza
East Elyria • Neighborhood Pizzeria With Italian Staples • Best For Groups And Variety
Sambino’s is where you go when some people want pizza and others want pasta or subs.
Sambino’s combines a solid pizza lineup with a broader Italian-inspired menu, making it easy to feed a mixed crowd. You can pair a sausage-and-peppers pie with wings, baked pasta, or a hefty sub without feeling like you compromised. It’s especially handy for family gatherings or casual nights when everyone wants something a little different.
04
Chain with a local following
Romeo's Pizza
Suburban Elyria • Handcrafted Ohio Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Game-Day Delivery
Romeo’s serves up thick-edged, sauce-forward pies that are built for sharing during the big game.
Romeo’s brings a slightly more modern chain feel, with signature crust options and saucier specialty pizzas than most old-school shops in town. It’s especially popular for delivery on game nights thanks to consistent timing and portions that easily feed a crowd. Try one of their loaded specialty pies if you want something beyond the standard pepperoni-and-cheese routine.
05
Family-friendly takeout
Marco's Pizza
Chestnut Commons Area • Casual Takeout And Delivery Chain • Family Dinner Standby
Marco’s is a go-to for families who want reliable, budget-friendly pizza with plenty of topping options.
Marco’s offers a broad menu—pizzas, cheesy bread, subs, and salads—making it an easy one-call solution for a busy weeknight. The crust is a touch thicker and softer than many local spots, and the customizable toppings let everyone build their own ideal pie. It’s the kind of place you keep on speed dial when you’re feeding kids, teammates, or neighbors on short notice.