01
Best overall pick
Pizzaroni's Pizza
Etna • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A small Etna shop turning out generous, no-nonsense pies with a loyal local following.
Pizzaroni's is the kind of place where the staff recognize regulars and the crust is sturdy enough to handle every topping you can throw at it. The menu leans classic—pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese are the stars—but everything is done with care and consistent bake. It’s the spot most Etna residents name first when someone asks where to get a solid, satisfying pizza without leaving town.
02
Coziest family spot
Grapevine Pizza & Cafe
Pickerington • Family-Friendly Italian Cafe • Best For Families
A relaxed Pickerington standby where pizza night feels like a sit-down family dinner.
Grapevine mixes a neighborhood pizza joint with a casual Italian cafe, making it an easy choice when you’ve got a mix of ages and appetites. The pizzas come with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, and there are enough pastas and salads to keep non-pizza people happy. It’s close enough to Etna for a weeknight drive, especially when you want to linger over a meal instead of grabbing a quick box to go.
03
Go-to delivery night
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Pataskala • Fast-Casual Delivery Shop • Best For Delivery
A dependable Pataskala outpost known for timely delivery and well-topped pies.
Flyers is a regional favorite for those nights when no one wants to cook and you want your order to arrive exactly as requested. The crust leans toward classic Columbus-style, with edge-to-edge toppings and a good balance of sauce and cheese. Subs, wings, and salads round things out, making it easy to feed a crowd spread between Etna, Pataskala, and nearby neighborhoods.
04
Best for game days
Pizza Cottage
Pickerington • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Groups
A bustling Pickerington spot built for big pies, big groups, and big-game energy.
Pizza Cottage feels like a natural choice when you’ve got friends in from out of town or want a place with enough noise that kids won’t stand out. Pizzas come in hearty sizes with plenty of specialty combinations, and there’s a full spread of appetizers to share across the table. From Etna, it’s a quick hop that pays off when you want space, TVs, and a stack of hot pizzas arriving one after another.
05
Classic Columbus-style pick
Massey's Pizza
Reynoldsburg • Old-School Columbus-Style Joint • Thin-Crust Traditionalist Pick
A long-running Reynoldsburg shop specializing in thin, square-cut Columbus-style pies.
If you’re chasing that classic Columbus-style experience—cracker-thin crust, square slices, and toppings spread right to the edge—Massey’s is worth the short drive from Etna. The pies are built for sharing, with crisp edges and a generous layer of pepperoni or sausage. It’s a great option when you want something a little different from the usual chain fare but still fast, familiar, and easy to eat by the slice.