01
Best overall pick
Trophy Pizza - Evendale
Evendale Village Center • Craft Pizza Shop • Local Favorite
Creative pies, a crackly crust, and friendly counter service make Trophy Pizza the no-brainer choice right in Evendale.
Trophy Pizza turns out thoughtfully topped pies with a dough that hits the sweet spot between chewy and crisp, plus plenty of build-your-own options. It’s an easy weeknight standby for nearby offices and residents, with quick takeout and a steady lunch rush. If you like to tinker, start with a classic cheese and layer on their rotating specialty toppings.
02
Classic crowd-pleaser
Roc-A-Fella's Pizza
Sharonville • New York-Style Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Generous New York-style pies, foldable slices, and plenty of seating make Roc-A-Fella’s a reliable choice for feeding a crowd.
Just up the road in Sharonville, Roc-A-Fella’s is the place to go when you want classic pizza with no fuss and lots of cheese. The crust is thin but sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and the oversized pies are easy to split among family or co-workers. Add in wings, subs, and salads and you can cover everyone’s order in a single stop.
03
Destination pie
TAGLIO Bar + Pizzeria (Montgomery)
Montgomery • Detroit-Style And Bar Pizza Spot • Best For Pizza Obsessives
TAGLIO’s caramelized-edge Detroit-style pizzas and inventive topping combos are worth the short drive from Evendale.
Head east to Montgomery for thick, airy Detroit-style squares with crisp, lacy cheese around the edges and bold flavor pairings. The menu reads like a pizza fan’s wish list, from spicy options to white pies and well-executed classics. It’s an ideal choice when you want to make dinner feel like more of an outing without trekking all the way downtown.
04
Family dinner standby
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Near Kenwood • Casual Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Best For Family Dinners
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta combines comforting pies with hearty pastas, making it an easy pick when not everyone at the table just wants pizza.
Situated along Montgomery Road near Kenwood, this spot feels like the classic neighborhood Italian place, with big booths and bigger portions. The pizza leans New York-style, with plenty of topping choices and a sauce that’s just sweet enough. It’s a go-to when you’re mixing kids, grandparents, and everyone in between and need a menu broad enough to keep the whole crew happy.
05
Suburban slice stop
Fratelli's Pizzeria
West Chester • Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Carryout And Delivery Pick
Fratelli’s is a north-of-Evendale favorite for well-loaded pies, hearty subs, and dependable takeout.
A quick hop up I-75, Fratelli’s serves the kind of straightforward, satisfying pizza that anchors many a busy weeknight. Crusts are sturdy with a nice chew, toppings are applied generously, and the menu has enough variety to keep repeat orders from feeling stale. It’s especially handy if you live or work closer to West Chester but still want something that feels like a local independent shop.