Fairview sits in the rolling hills between Cambridge and St. Clairsville, so the best pizza requires a short but rewarding drive. From Ohio Valley-style square-cut pies to loaded carry-out specials, these nearby shops are where locals head when a craving hits. Whether you are coming off I-70 or winding in from the back roads, these five stops cover the region’s most reliable slices.
A regional staple known for generously topped, square-cut pies that travel well back to Fairview.
DeFelice Bros. is the classic Ohio Valley choice if you do not mind the easy hop over to St. Clairsville. The pizza comes piled with toppings, with that slightly chewy crust that holds up in the box on the ride home. It is a go-to for anyone wanting a local name instead of a national chain logo on the box.
A flexible, build-your-own style shop with plenty of crust, topping, and size options for a crowd.
Creno's in Cambridge is a handy stop when you are feeding a mix of tastes and appetites. The menu leans into customization, from classic pepperoni to fully loaded works pies and thick, filling crusts. Call ahead from Fairview, swing through town, and you can be back home with a stack of hot boxes in short order.
Trusted for consistent pies, online ordering, and late-night hours when other spots are dark.
When you need something predictable and fast, the Cambridge Domino's is the easiest call from Fairview. Online ordering, app deals, and delivery tracking make it simple to time your pickup or delivery. It is not trying to be gourmet, but for a quick, hot pizza on a busy weeknight, it more than does the job.
Classic pan pizzas, breadsticks, and sit-down booths that work well for a family night out from Fairview.
Cambridge’s Pizza Hut is the familiar choice when you want that thick, buttery pan crust and a pitcher of soda on the table. It is an easy meeting point if friends are coming from different directions along I-70. Many Fairview families pair errands in town with a relaxed meal here before heading back into the country.
A homey shop turning out thick, cheesy pies and oven-baked subs that feel made for game night.
Giovanni's in Barnesville has the kind of old-school feel people expect from a village pizza place. Pies are substantial, with plenty of cheese and classic toppings, and the subs are hefty enough to split. It is a favorite detour for Fairview residents heading toward Barnesville for errands or a Friday night ball game.