01
Best overall pick
LaRosa's Pizzeria Mt. Orab
Mount Orab Near Oh-32 • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A busy LaRosa's outpost that reliably turns out crowd-pleasing pies for both dine-in and takeout.
This Mount Orab LaRosa's is where a lot of Fayetteville folks head when they want pizza that feels like a night out without driving into the city. The crust is on the softer, saucier side, with plenty of classic toppings and a few specialty combinations locals swear by. Service is quick, and the dining room works just as well for kids’ teams as it does for a casual date night.
02
Best for delivery night
Snappy Tomato Pizza Mt. Orab
Mount Orab Village Center • Fast Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Delivery
Go-to spot when you want a big, shareable pizza dropped at the door without much fuss.
Snappy Tomato in Mount Orab leans into generous portions, from their well-known party pizzas to thick, cheesy specialty pies. The menu is built for feeding a crowd, with plenty of sides and deals that make weeknight delivery less of a splurge. It’s not fancy, but the convenience and consistency make it a staple in the Fayetteville area.
03
Best small-town classic
Grandma's Pizza & Pasta Sardinia
Sardinia Just Off Us-62 • Old-School Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Small-Town Classic
A cozy, no-rush shop turning out thick, cheesy pies and hearty pasta that feel straight from a family kitchen.
Grandma's in Sardinia has the kind of slightly sweet sauce and generous cheese that many southern Ohio pizza fans grow up on. The crust runs on the thicker side, great for loading up with toppings or pairing with an order of pasta. It’s a relaxed, hometown stop when you want comfort food rather than something overly polished.
04
Best for family dinners
LaRosa's Pizzeria Bethel
Bethel Along Oh-125 • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria With Full Menu • Best For Families
A roomy LaRosa's location that makes it easy to gather the family around a couple of big pies and some shareable sides.
The Bethel LaRosa's is a comfortable choice when you’re coming in from different directions and need a central meeting point. Beyond the familiar pizzas, there are wings, salads, and pastas, so even non–pizza lovers can find something. Staff is used to handling large parties, which makes it a reliable pick for birthdays and team celebrations.
05
Best budget-friendly slices
Angilo's Pizza Blanchester
Blanchester Main Strip • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Best Value
Classic Ohio-style pies at friendly prices, served in a simple space locals have been hitting for years.
Angilo's in Blanchester leans into straightforward, thin-to-medium crust pizzas with a crisp edge and plenty of toppings. The vibe is old-school and unpretentious, the kind of place where staff know the regulars’ orders by heart. It’s an easy detour from Fayetteville when you care more about taste and value than décor.