01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Side Near I-75 • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Big, shareable pizzas and a long tap list make Beer Barrel a go-to for crowds and game nights.
Expect generous toppings, crisp-edged crusts, and plenty of classic and specialty combinations, all served in a bustling dining room with lots of TVs. It is an easy choice for families, teams, or meetups where everyone wants something a little different, from pizza and wings to salads and burgers. Go early on weekends if you want a quieter corner and a shorter wait.
02
Classic local staple
Jac & Do's Pizza
North Main Corridor • No-Frills Hometown Pizza Joint • Best For A Casual Slice
Jac & Do's is a long-running local favorite known for its straightforward, satisfying pies at fair prices.
This is the kind of place locals grew up on: familiar toppings, dependable crust, and a laid-back atmosphere that does not try too hard. The menu is built around classic combinations, but you can easily customize your own pie for carryout or a relaxed dine-in meal. It is especially handy when you want an easy, no-drama pizza night that still feels local.
03
Neighborhood delivery hero
Heavenly Pizza
Central Findlay • Carryout And Delivery Pie Shop • Best For Delivery Night
Heavenly Pizza is a hometown shop known for hearty, topping-heavy pies and reliable delivery around Findlay.
Crusts lean on the thicker, chewier side, built to handle plenty of cheese and toppings without getting soggy. Beyond pizza, their subs and sides make it easy to feed a mixed group without cooking a thing. It is the spot locals save in their phones for those nights when everyone wants comfort food to show up at the door.
04
Detroit-style specialist
Doughtroit
Tiffin Avenue Strip • Detroit-Style Specialty Shop • Best For Thick, Cheesy Slices
Doughtroit leans into Detroit-style pizza with tall, airy crusts, caramelized cheese edges, and bold toppings.
If you like your pizza more like a pan-baked feast, this is the place to seek out in Findlay. The square pies come out with a crisp bottom, a light interior, and cheese that runs right to the edge, giving each slice those coveted crunchy corners. It is a great option when you want something different from standard round pies and are in the mood to really indulge.
05
Best pizza and sandwich combo
Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders
West Side • Casual Family Spot • Best For Mixed Cravings
Bellacino's balances solid pizzas with a deep lineup of hot grinders, making it ideal for groups who do not all want the same thing.
The pizza here is classic and customizable, with a crust that holds up well under generous cheese and toppings. What really sets it apart is the grinder menu, so one person can dig into a loaded oven-baked sandwich while another sticks to a traditional pie. It is a relaxed, family-friendly choice when you need a one-stop shop for dinner.