01
Best overall pick
3 Joe's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Downtown Piqua • Lively Trattoria With Hand-Tossed Pies • Go-To For Classic And Specialty Pizzas
A polished yet comfortable Italian spot where the pizza is as much of a draw as the pasta and wine list.
3 Joe's is where many locals send visitors when they ask for the best pizza around Piqua and Fletcher. The crust strikes a balance between chewy and crisp, with plenty of topping choices and well-seasoned sauce. It works just as well for a relaxed family meal as it does for lingering over a carafe of wine with friends.
02
Best for date night
La Piazza
Downtown Troy • Upscale Italian Restaurant With Wood-Fired Pizza • Great For Lingering Dinners And Wine
An inviting downtown Troy dining room serving refined Italian dishes and thoughtfully crafted pizzas.
Set on Troy’s historic square, La Piazza feels a little more special than your average pizzeria, with a menu that treats pizza as seriously as its pastas. The pies come with well-curated toppings, from classic margherita to richer combinations that pair nicely with a glass of wine. It is an easy choice when you want pizza but also want a sit-down evening out.
03
Dayton-style icon
Marion's Piazza
North Troy Near I-75 • Spacious, Family-Friendly Pizza Hall • Top Pick For Big Groups
A long-running regional favorite known for ultra-thin, square-cut pies piled edge-to-edge with toppings.
Marion's brings the classic Dayton-style experience to Troy, making it a natural gathering spot for teams, birthdays, and casual meetups. The crust is crisp, the toppings are generous, and the atmosphere is unfussy enough that nobody worries about making a mess. It is an ideal choice when you need to feed a crowd after a game or school event near Fletcher.
04
Small-town favorite
Pizza Alley
Downtown Saint Paris • Casual Carryout And Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Quick, Budget-Friendly Pies
A no-frills local shop turning out hearty pizzas that hit the spot on a weeknight.
Just southeast of Fletcher, Pizza Alley has the feel of a true small-town hangout, with straightforward pies, friendly service, and prices that keep regulars coming back. The crust is satisfyingly chewy, and the toppings lean generous rather than fussy. It is a smart stop when you want something easy on the wallet without defaulting to a national chain.
05
Old-school thin crust
Cassano's Pizza King
East Piqua Near Us-36 • Classic Dayton-Style Pizza Shop • Best For Nostalgic Takeout Nights
A regional staple offering cracker-thin, square-cut pies that taste like childhood to many Miami Valley locals.
Cassano's has been part of the area’s pizza story for decades, and the Piqua location is a convenient option for Fletcher residents. Expect a super-thin crust, finely chopped toppings, and that distinctive Dayton-style cut that makes sharing easy. Call ahead for takeout, then enjoy it at home or at a nearby park on a warm evening.