01
Best overall pick
Carpenter's Pizza
High Street In Flushing Village • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
The kind of no-fuss village pizza shop where the crust is sturdy, the cheese is generous, and everyone seems to know each other.
If you ask around Flushing where to get a pie without leaving town, Carpenter's is the name that comes up first. The menu sticks to familiar territory—pepperoni, sausage, and loaded specials—but the dough has that just-right chew and the toppings are piled on with a hometown generosity. Call ahead on busy evenings; the shop is small, and locals rely on it for everything from weeknight dinners to post-game pizza runs.
02
Essential Ohio Valley classic
DiCarlo's Pizza
Downtown Wheeling • Square-Cut Ohio Valley-Style Shop • Best For Old-School Slices
A short drive from Flushing gets you to legendary square-cut pizza with sauce and hot crust topped by a blizzard of fresh, unmelted cheese.
DiCarlo's is a rite of passage for anyone exploring pizza in the Upper Ohio Valley, and it is close enough to Flushing to make an easy outing. The signature move is baking the crust and sauce, then layering on cold provolone as it comes out of the oven, giving each bite a mix of hot and cool. It is a simple formula, served on humble trays, but the nostalgic flavor and quick counter service make it worth the drive.
03
Family-night standby
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Shopping Corridor In St. Clairsville • Casual Regional Pizza Chain • Best For Sharing With A Crowd
Hearty, topping-heavy pizzas and shareable sides make this a reliable choice before or after a trip to the St. Clairsville shops.
DeFelice Bros. is a regional name locals know, and the St. Clairsville location is convenient if you are already in town for errands or the mall. The crust leans soft and bready, built to hold serious amounts of cheese, pepperoni, and vegetables, and the menu extends into subs, wings, and salads. It is the sort of place where ordering a couple of extra-large specialty pies easily feeds a mixed group of kids and adults.
04
Reliable delivery option
Vocelli Pizza
Near The I-70 Corridor In St. Clairsville • Chain Pizzeria With Customizable Options • Best For Takeout And Delivery
A convenient stop for build-your-own pies, flavored crusts, and quick delivery back toward Flushing.
Vocelli offers a wide range of crusts, sauces, and toppings, which is helpful when everyone in the car has a different idea of the perfect pizza. The St. Clairsville shop is easy to reach from the interstate, so you can swing by on the way home or have an order sent out toward the eastern Belmont County backroads. Beyond pizza, the breadsticks, wings, and dessert options round out a full takeout spread without much planning.
05
Sit-down Italian with pizza
Figaretti's Restaurant
National Road In Wheeling • Cozy Italian Restaurant Serving Pizza • Best For A Lingering Dinner
A longtime Wheeling favorite where you can pair a hand-tossed pie with pasta, salad, and a relaxed, old-school dining room.
When pizza night feels like an excuse for a proper sit-down meal, Figaretti's makes a great destination from Flushing. Known first for red-sauce Italian classics, the restaurant also turns out satisfying pizzas with a flavorful crust and well-seasoned toppings. Expect a warm, lived-in atmosphere, friendly service, and portions big enough that you are likely to leave with leftovers for the next day's lunch.