01
Best overall pick
Lucy Blue Pizza – Anderson
Anderson Township • Late-Night Slice Shop • Local Favorite
A beloved Cincinnati mini-chain with an east-side shop turning out hefty slices and whole pies on Clough Pike.[1][2]
Lucy Blue’s Anderson location brings the downtown slice-shop energy closer to Forestville, with foldable slices, creative topping combos, and whole pies for sharing.[1][2] It’s casual and unfussy, making it an easy go-to for last-minute pizza nights or a quick bite after errands on the east side.[1][2] Expect a neighborhood feel, steady takeout traffic, and reliably satisfying pies rather than fussy, overcomplicated creations.[1]
02
Best New York-style slices
Ramundo’s Pizzeria
Mt. Lookout • Classic New York-Style Pizzeria • Best For Big Slices
A Cincinnati standby known for oversized New York-style slices and a laid-back, late-night-friendly vibe in Mt. Lookout.[1][3]
Ramundo’s has built a loyal following for its massive, thin-but-foldable slices topped with straightforward, crowd-pleasing combinations.[1][3] The Mt. Lookout shop feels like a true neighborhood pizzeria, with a steady stream of locals grabbing slices, whole pies, and garlic knots before or after a night out.[1][3] It’s an easy choice when you want classic, no-frills pizza in generous portions after a short drive from Forestville toward the city.[1]
03
Best Detroit-style pies
TAGLIO Bar + Pizzeria
Columbia-Tusculum • Detroit-Style Bar Pizzeria • Best For Craft Toppings
Detroit-style, pan-baked pies with caramelized, crispy edges and inventive toppings in a lively east-side setting.[1][3]
TAGLIO’s Columbia-Tusculum location specializes in thick, airy, square-cut Detroit-style pizzas with a golden, crisped cheese crust around the edges.[1][3] Toppings lean modern—think spicy meats, drizzles, and fresh herbs—making it a good pick when you want something a bit more chef-driven than a basic pepperoni.[1][3] With its bar-forward setting and shareable pies, it works as well for a casual date or drinks with friends as it does for elevated takeout.[1]
04
Best destination pie
Joe’s Pizza Napoli
Milford – Chamber Drive • Artisan Pizza Spot • Best For Date Night
A Milford favorite drawing serious pizza fans for carefully crafted pies and a cozy, sit-down experience.[1]
Joe’s Pizza Napoli on Chamber Drive in Milford has become a destination for east-side pizza lovers willing to go a bit farther for a standout pie.[1] Pizzas here are thoughtfully built, with quality ingredients and a crust that shows real care, making it a natural pick for a low-key date night or a lingering meal with friends.[1] It feels more like a small, specialty restaurant than a grab-and-go slice joint, so plan to slow down and stay awhile.[1]
05
Best for groups
Padrino Italian
Historic Downtown Milford • Family-Friendly Italian Restaurant • Best For Families And Groups
A lively Italian spot on Main Street in downtown Milford where pizza shares the menu with pastas, apps, and crowd-pleasing classics.[1]
Padrino sits right on Main Street in historic Milford, pairing a full Italian menu with solid, shareable pizzas that work for a wide range of tastes.[1] The roomy dining area and flexible menu make it especially handy when you are feeding a group that wants more than just pizza—think salads, pastas, and appetizers alongside a few big pies.[1] It’s the kind of place you can bring kids, out-of-town guests, or a mixed group and still count on an easy, satisfying meal within a reasonable drive of Forestville.[1]