01
Best overall pick
Keyhole Pizza
Fort Loramie Village Center • Family-Run Pizza And Sub Shop • Local Favorite
A go-to Fort Loramie spot known for generous toppings, friendly service, and late-night hours.
Keyhole Pizza is the kind of place that feels woven into everyday life in Fort Loramie, from Friday night carryout to post-game team dinners. The pies are classic Midwest-style—plenty of cheese, a solid crust, and toppings piled on without being fussy. It’s an easy choice when you want consistently good pizza and a small-town welcoming vibe.
02
Classic village staple
Al's Place
North Side Of Fort Loramie • Casual Pizza, Subs, And Comfort-Food Spot • Best For Families
A long-running hometown standby serving pizza alongside burgers, tenderloins, and other comfort favorites.
Al's Place has been feeding Fort Loramie for decades, and the pizza is a big part of why people keep coming back. Expect a laid-back, family-friendly setting where you can pair a hot pie with wings, sandwiches, or a big tenderloin. It’s the kind of all-purpose local joint that works just as well for a quick weeknight dinner as it does for a gathering after a local game.
03
Short-drive standout
Bud's Pizza
In Minster, A Short Drive South • Small-Town Pizzeria With Bar-Style Pies • Best For A Night Out With Friends
A beloved Minster mainstay turning out crisp, shareable pizzas that pair well with a casual night out.
Bud's Pizza in nearby Minster is worth the quick drive when you’re in the mood for a slightly livelier scene with your slice. The crust tends to the thinner, crispier side, making it ideal for sharing several pizzas with a group. Many locals make an evening of it here before or after events, so it’s a good pick when you want pizza plus a bit of small-town energy.
04
Dependable takeout option
Padrone's Pizza
In Anna Along The I-75 Corridor • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Takeout
A reliable Anna stop for customizable pies, wings, and other game-night staples to bring back home or to the campsite.
Padrone's Pizza in Anna is especially handy when you want to grab a few hot pies on the way home or back to the lake. The menu leans into build-your-own combinations, with plenty of toppings and sauces to tweak things just how you like them. It’s a solid, straightforward choice when convenience matters as much as a good, crowd-pleasing pizza.
05
Retro Ohio-style choice
Cassano's Pizza King
In Sidney, Regional Hub East Of Fort Loramie • Classic Ohio Thin-Crust Chain Outpost • Best For Nostalgic Ohio-Style Pizza
A Sidney favorite for cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a nostalgic Ohio pizzeria feel.
Cassano's Pizza King in Sidney brings a distinctly regional style: ultra-thin, crispy crust cut into small squares with toppings spread right to the edge. Many locals grew up on this style and still make the drive when the craving hits. If you want to taste a piece of wider western Ohio pizza history, this is the stop to add to your Fort Loramie-area rotation.