01
Best overall pick
Cristy's Pizza – Chillicothe
Chillicothe – North Bridge Street • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Variety
Square-cut thin crust, lots of topping combos, and fair prices make Cristy’s an easy go-to from Frankfort.
Cristy’s leans into that classic central-Ohio style: a crisp, thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and pies cut into small squares that are perfect for sharing. The menu runs from simple pepperoni to loaded specialty pizzas, plus a few pastas and subs if someone in the group wants something different. It’s an easy stop if you’re already running errands on Bridge Street and want to bring a couple of large pies back to Frankfort.
02
Best for edge-to-edge toppings
Donatos Pizza – Chillicothe
Chillicothe – Western Avenue Corridor • Thin-Crust Chain With Edge-To-Edge Toppings • Best For Consistent Quality
Donatos delivers that familiar crispy crust with toppings pushed all the way to the edge, plus reliable online ordering.
If you like a thinner crust with plenty of crunch, Donatos hits the mark, especially on their pepperoni and specialty pies. Their online ordering is straightforward, so you can time pickup for the drive back toward Frankfort without waiting around. It’s a strong choice when you want predictable quality and toppings that don’t skimp, whether you’re feeding a couple of people or a whole team.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza – Chillicothe
Chillicothe – Near Downtown • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
Domino’s is the practical option for customizable crusts, quick service, and late-evening orders after a long day.
Domino’s offers a mix of hand-tossed, thin, and pan crusts, so everyone in the group can land on something they like. The appeal here is speed and convenience: online deals, order tracking, and hours that run later than many smaller spots. It’s the kind of place Frankfort locals rely on when practices run long, games go into extra innings, or you simply don’t feel like cooking after dark.
04
Best sit-down classic
Pizza Hut – Western Avenue
Chillicothe – Western Avenue • Family-Friendly Dine-In And Carryout • Best For Families
This Pizza Hut is the familiar choice for pan pizza, breadsticks, and a sit-down meal that works for kids and groups.
For families coming in from Frankfort, Pizza Hut’s Western Avenue location is an easy, kid-friendly stop where everyone knows the menu. The thick pan crust, cheesy stuffed crust, and seasoned breadsticks still feel like a treat, especially if you’re making a night of it after shopping in Chillicothe. It’s also handy for big orders when you need several large pies and don’t want to overthink it.
05
Best budget-friendly stop
Little Caesars Pizza – Chillicothe
Chillicothe – Retail Strip Near North Bridge Street • Grab-And-Go Carryout Spot • Fastest Budget Option
Little Caesars is the quick, low-cost answer when you want to grab a couple of pizzas on the way back to Frankfort.
Little Caesars leans hard into speed and value, with Hot-N-Ready pies and crazy bread that are usually ready as soon as you walk in. It’s a smart move if you’re passing through Chillicothe and need to feed a crowd without blowing the budget. Pick up a few large pepperoni or a stuffed-crust option, and you’re back on the road to Frankfort in minutes.